The SCARE Statement: Consensus-based surgical case report guidelines

被引：843

作者：

Agha, Riaz A. ^{[1
]}

Fowler, Alexander J. ^{[2
]}

Saeta, Alexandra ^{[2
]}

Barai, Ishani ^{[3
]}

Rajmohan, Shivanchan ^{[3
]}

Orgill, Dennis P. ^{[4
]}

Afifi, Raafat ^{[5
]}

Al-Ahmadi, Raha ^{[6
]}

Albrecht, Joerg ^{[7
]}

Alsawadi, Abdulrahman ^{[8
]}

Aronson, Jeffrey ^{[9
]}

Ather, M. Hammad ^{[10
]}

Bashashati, Mohammad ^{[11
]}

Basu, Somprakas ^{[12
]}

Bradley, Patrick ^{[13
]}

Chalkoo, Mushtaq

Challacombe, Ben ^{[14
]}

Cross, Trent ^{[15
]}

Derbyshire, Laura ^{[16
]}

Farooq, Naheed ^{[17
]}

Hoffman, Jerome ^{[18
]}

Kadioglu, Huseyin ^{[19
]}

Kasivisvanathan, Veeru ^{[20
]}

Kirshtein, Boris ^{[21
]}

Klappenbach, Roberto ^{[22
]}

Laskin, Daniel ^{[23
]}

Miguel, Diana ^{[24
]}

Milburn, James ^{[25
]}

Mousavi, Seyed Reza ^{[26
]}

Muensterer, Oliver ^{[27
]}

Ngu, James ^{[28
]}

Nixon, Iain ^{[29
]}

Noureldin, Ashraf ^{[30
]}

Perakath, Benjamin ^{[31
]}

Raison, Nicholas ^{[32
]}

Raveendran, Kandiah ^{[33
]}

Sullivan, Timothy ^{[34
]}

Thoma, Achilleas ^{[35
]}

Thorat, Mangesh ^{[36
]}

Valmasoni, Michele ^{[37
]}

Massarut, Samuele ^{[38
]}

D'cruz, Anil ^{[39
]}

Vasudevan, Baskaran ^{[40
]}

Giordano, Salvatore ^{[41
]}

Roy, Gaurav ^{[42
]}

Healy, Donagh ^{[43
]}

Machado-Aranda, David ^{[44
]}

Carroll, Bryan ^{[45
]}

Rosin, David ^{[46
]}

机构：

[1] Guys & St Thomas NHS Fdn Trust, Dept Plast Surg, Westminster Bridge Rd, London SE1 7EH, England

[2] Guys & St Thomas NHS Fdn Trust, Dept Med, London, England

[3] Imperial Coll, Sch Med, London, England

[4] Brigham & Womens Hosp, Div Plast Surg, 75 Francis St, Boston, MA 02115 USA

[5] Cairo Univ, Cairo, Egypt

[6] King Faisal Specialist Hosp & Res Ctr, Jeddah, Saudi Arabia

[7] John H Stroger Jr Hosp Cook Cty, Chicago, IL USA

[8] Colchester Hosp Univ NHS Fdn Trust, Colchester, Essex, England

[9] Radcliffe Infirm, Oxford, England

[10] Aga Khan Univ, Karachi, Pakistan

[11] Texas Tech Univ, Hlth Sci Ctr, Lubbock, TX 79409 USA

[12] Banaras Hindu Univ, Varanasi 221005, Uttar Pradesh, India

[13] Univ Nottingham Hosp, Nottingham, England

[14] Guys & St Thomas NHS Fdn Trust, London, England

[15] James Cook Univ, Townsville, Qld, Australia

[16] North West Deanery, Manchester, Lancs, England

[17] Cent Manchester Univ Hosp Fdn Trust, Manchester, Lancs, England

[18] Univ Calif Los Angeles, Los Angeles, CA 90024 USA

[19] Bezmialem Vakif Univ, Istanbul, Turkey

[20] UCL, London WC1E 6BT, England

[21] Soroka Univ Med Ctr, Beer Sheva, Israel

[22] Simplemente Evita Hosp, Buenos Aires, DF, Argentina

[23] Virginia Commonwealth Univ, Richmond, VA 23284 USA

[24] Univ Hosp Jena, Jena, Germany

[25] Queens Med Ctr, Nottingham, England

[26] Shohada Med Ctr Tajrish, Tajrish Tehran, Iran

[27] Univ Med Mainz, Mainz, Germany

[28] Changi Gen Hosp, Singapore, Singapore

[29] East Kent Univ Hosp, Ashford, Kent, England

[30] Cumberland Royal Infirm, Carlisle, England

[31] Dr Grays Hosp, Elgin, Scotland

[32] Kings Coll London, London WC2R 2LS, England

[33] Fatimah Hosp, Ipoh, Perak, Malaysia

[34] Minneapolis Heart Inst, Minneapolis, MN USA

[35] McMaster Univ, Hamilton, ON L8S 4L8, Canada

[36] Queen Mary Univ London, Wolfson Inst Prevent Med, London, England

[37] Univ Padua, I-35100 Padua, Italy

[38] Ctr Riferimento Oncol, Aviano, Italy

[39] Tata Mem Hosp, Bombay, Maharashtra, India

[40] MIOT Hosp, Madras, Tamil Nadu, India

[41] Turku Univ Hosp, Turku, Finland

[42] Medanta The Medic, Gurgaon, Haryana, India

[43] Univ Hosp Waterford, Waterford, Ireland

[44] Univ Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI 48109 USA

[45] Eastern Virginia Med Sch, Norfolk, VA USA

[46] Univ West Indies, Wanstead, Barbados

来源：

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF SURGERY | 2016年 / 34卷

关键词：

Guideline; CARE; Case report; Surgery;

D O I：

10.1016/j.ijsu.2016.08.014

中图分类号：

R61 [外科手术学];

学科分类号：

摘要：

Introduction: Case reports have been a long held tradition within the surgical literature. Reporting guidelines can improve transparency and reporting quality. However, recent consensus-based guidelines for case reports (CARE) are not surgically focused. Our objective was to develop surgical case report guidelines. Methods: The CARE statement was used as the basis for a Delphi consensus. The Delphi questionnaire was administered via Google Forms and conducted using standard Delphi methodology. A multidisciplinary group of surgeons and others with expertise in the reporting of case reports were invited to participate. In round one, participants stated how each item of the CARE statement should be changed and what additional items were needed. Revised and additional items from round one were put forward into a further round, where participants voted on the extent of their agreement with each item, using a nine-point Likert scale, as proposed by the Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development and Evaluations (GRADE) working group. Results: In round one, there was a 64% (38/59) response rate. Following adjustment of the guideline with the incorporation of recommended changes, round two commenced and there was an 83% (49/59) response rate. All but one of the items were approved by the participants, with Likert scores 7-9 awarded by >70% of respondents. The final guideline consists of a 14-item checklist. Conclusion: We present the SCARE Guideline, consisting of a 14-item checklist that will improve the reporting quality of surgical case reports. (C) 2016 IJS Publishing Group Ltd. Published by Elsevier Ltd. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).

引用

页码：180 / 186

页数：7

共 13 条

[1]

Agha R, 2010, INT J SURG, V8, P330, DOI [10.1016/j.ijsu.2010.05.003, 10.1016/j.ijscr.2010.04.001]

[2] A protocol for the development of reporting criteria for surgical case reports: The SCARE statement [J].

Agha, Riaz A. ;

Fowler, Alexander J. ;

Saetta, Alexandra ;

Barai, Ishani ;

Rajmohan, Shivanchan ;

Orgill, Dennis P. .

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF SURGERY, 2016, 27 :187-189

[3] The CARE guidelines: consensus-based clinical case report guideline development [J].

Gagnier, Joel J. ;

Kienle, Gunver ;

Altman, Douglas G. ;

Moher, David ;

Sox, Harold ;

Riley, David .

JOURNAL OF CLINICAL EPIDEMIOLOGY, 2014, 67 (01) :46-51

[4] HOW TO WRITE A CASE REPORT FOR PUBLICATION [J].

Green, Bart N. ;

Johnson, Claire D. .

JOURNAL OF CHIROPRACTIC MEDICINE, 2006, 5 (02) :72-82

[5] How can we improve surgical research and innovation?: The IDEAL framework for action [J].

Hirst, Allison ;

Agha, Riaz A. ;

Rosin, David ;

McCulloch, Peter .

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF SURGERY, 2013, 11 (10) :1038-1042

[6] The case report - an endangered species? [J].

Mason, RA .

ANAESTHESIA, 2001, 56 (02) :99-102

[7] Surgical Innovation and Evaluation 3 No surgical innovation without evaluation: the IDEAL recommendations [J].

McCulloch, Peter ;

Altman, Douglas G. ;

Campbell, W. Bruce ;

Flum, David R. ;

Glasziou, Paul ;

Marshall, John C. ;

Nicholl, Jon .

LANCET, 2009, 374 (9695) :1105-1112

[8] Guidance for Developers of Health Research Reporting Guidelines [J].

Moher, David ;

Schulz, Kenneth F. ;

Simera, Iveta ;

Altman, Douglas G. .

PLOS MEDICINE, 2010, 7 (02)

[9]

Nissen T, 2014, JRSM OPEN, V5

[10] Restoration of Facial Form and Function After Severe Disfigurement from Burn Injury by a Composite Facial Allograft [J].

Pomahac, B. ;

Pribaz, J. ;

Eriksson, E. ;

Annino, D. ;

Caterson, S. ;

Sampson, C. ;

Chun, Y. ;

Orgill, D. ;

Nowinski, D. ;

Tullius, S. G. .

AMERICAN JOURNAL OF TRANSPLANTATION, 2011, 11 (02) :386-393

← 1 2 →