Hydrophobic core substitutions in calbindin D9k:: Effects on stability and structure

The effects of hydrophobic core mutations on the stability and structure of the four-helix calcium-binding protein, calbindin D-9k, have been investigated. Eleven mutations involving: eight residues distributed within the hydrophobic core of calbindin D-9k were examined. Stabilities were measured by denaturant and thermal induced unfolding monitored by circular dichroism spectroscopy. The mutations were found to exert large effects on the stability with midpoints in the urea induced unfolding varying from 1.8 M for Leu23 --> Gly up to 6.6 M for Va170 --> Leu and free energies of unfolding in the absence of denaturant ranging from 6.6 to 27.4 kJ/mol for the Phe66 --> Ala mutant and the wild-type, respectively. A significant correlation was found between the difference in free energy of unfolding (Delta Delta G(NU)) and the change in the surface area of the side chain caused by the mutation, in agreement with other studies. Notably, both increases and decreases in side-chain surface area caused quantitatively equivalent effects on the stability. In other words, a correlation between the absolute value of the change in the surface of the side chain and Delta Delta G(NU) was observed with a value of approximately 0.14 kJ M-1 Angstrom(-2). The generality of this observation is discussed. Significant effects on the cooperativity of the unfolding reaction were also observed. However, a correlation between the cooperativity and Delta Delta G(NU), which has been reported in other systems as an indication of effects of mutations on the unfolded state, was not observed for calbindin D9k Despite the large effects on Delta Delta G(NU) and cooperativity, the structures of the mutants in the native form remained intact as indicated by circular dichroism, NMR, and fluorescence measurements. The structural response to calcium-binding was also conserved. The following paper in this issue [Kragelund, B. B., et al, (1998) Biochemistry 37, 8926-8937] examines the effects of these mutations on the calcium binding properties of calbindin D-9k.