Profile analysis with the Wechsler Scales - Why does it persist?

被引:15
作者
Bray, MA
Kehle, TJ
Hintze, JM
机构
[1] Univ Connecticut, Dept Educ Psychol, Storrs, CT 06269 USA
[2] St Johns Univ, Jamaica, NY 11439 USA
关键词
D O I
10.1177/0143034398193002
中图分类号
G44 [教育心理学];
学科分类号
0402 ; 040202 ;
摘要
Despite the overwhelming evidence that mitigates against the use of profile analysis, the practice of diagnosing specific cognitive or processing disabilities continues. The reason that profile analysis remains popular is probably because school psychologists are simply unfamiliar with the literature. They have a difficult time understanding the notion of g, along with its implications. Generally, the users of profile analysis assume that because the IQ tests, particularly the WISC scales, generate scores from subtests that differ in content, they must be measuring different types of cognitive abilities, and therefore the profile of these cognitive abilities should be diagnostically important. Finally, they find profile analysis more socially acceptable in that it implies the existence of multiple intelligences. The notion that a single IQ score captures all that is meaningful and practical about the IQ test is simply not acceptable, regardless of evidence to the contrary.
引用
收藏
页码:209 / 220
页数:12
相关论文
共 48 条
[1]  
*AMM PSYCH AS, 1992, AM PSYCHOL, V47, P1597
[2]  
BERK RA, 1982, J CLIN PSYCHOL, V38, P638, DOI 10.1002/1097-4679(198207)38:3<638::AID-JCLP2270380332>3.0.CO
[3]  
2-2
[4]  
Brody N., 1992, INTELLIGENCE
[5]   PROFILE ANALYSIS OF THE WECHSLER INTELLIGENCE SCALES - A NEW INDEX OF SUBTEST SCATTER [J].
BURGESS, A .
BRITISH JOURNAL OF CLINICAL PSYCHOLOGY, 1991, 30 :257-263
[6]  
CAHAN S, 1988, J PSYCHOEDUCATIONAL, V6, P107, DOI DOI 10.1177/073428298800600202
[7]   THE MAHALANOBIS DISTANCE INDEX OF WAIS-R SUBTEST SCATTER - PSYCHOMETRIC PROPERTIES IN A HEALTHY UK SAMPLE [J].
CRAWFORD, JR ;
ALLAN, KM .
BRITISH JOURNAL OF CLINICAL PSYCHOLOGY, 1994, 33 :65-69
[8]  
Cutts N.E., 1955, SCH PSYCHOL MID CENT
[9]  
Glutting J. J., 1997, Contemporary intellectual assessment: Theories, tests, and issues, P349
[10]   THE TREATMENT UTILITY OF ASSESSMENT - A FUNCTIONAL-APPROACH TO EVALUATING ASSESSMENT QUALITY [J].
HAYES, SC ;
NELSON, RO ;
JARRETT, RB .
AMERICAN PSYCHOLOGIST, 1987, 42 (11) :963-974