How well do we (and will we) know solar neutrino fluxes and oscillation parameters?

被引:75
作者
Bahcall, JN
Krastev, PI
机构
[1] School of Natural Sciences, Institute for Advanced Study, Princeton, NJ
关键词
D O I
10.1103/PhysRevD.53.4211
中图分类号
P1 [天文学];
学科分类号
0704 ;
摘要
Individual neutrino fluxes are not well determined by the four operating solar neutrino experiments. Assuming neutrino oscillations occur, the pp electron neutrino flux is uncertain by a factor of 2, the B-8 flux by a factor of 5, and the Be-7 flux by a factor of 45. For matter-enhanced oscillation (MSW) solutions, the range of allowed differences of squared neutrino masses, Delta m(2), varies between 4x10(-6) eV(2) and 1x10(-4) eV(2), while 4x10(-3)less than or equal to sin(2)2 theta less than or equal to 1.5x10(-2) or 0.5 less than or equal to sin(2)2 theta less than or equal to 0.9. For vacuum oscillations, Delta m(2) varies between 5x10(-11) eV(2) and 1x10(-10) eV(2), while 0.7 less than or equal to sin(2) theta less than or equal to 1.0. The inferred ranges of neutrino parameters depend only weakly on which standard solar model is used. Calculations of the expected results of future solar neutrino experiments (SuperKamiokande, SNO, BOREXINO, ICARUS, HELLAZ, and HERON) are used to illustrate the extent to which these experiments will restrict the range of the allowed neutrino mixing parameters. For example, the double ratio (observed ratio divided by standard model ratio) of neutral current to charged current event rates to be measured in the SNO experiment varies, at 95% confidence limit, over the range 1.0 (no oscillations into active neutrinos), 3.1(-1.3)(+1.8) (small mixing angle MSW), 4.4(-1.4)(+2.0) (large mixing angle MSW), and 5.2(-2.9)(+5.6) (vacuum oscillations). We present an improved formulation of the ''luminosity constraint'' and show that at 95% confidence limit, this constraint establishes the best available limits on the rate of creation of pp neutrinos in the solar interior and provides the best upper limit to the Be-7 neutrino flux. The actual rate of creation of solar neutrinos in the solar interior to the rate predicted by the standard solar model can vary (while holding the CNO neutrino flux constant) between 0.55 and 1.08 for pp neutrinos and between 0.0 and 6.35 for Be-7 neutrinos.
引用
收藏
页码:4211 / 4225
页数:15
相关论文
共 82 条
  • [1] RESULTS FROM SAGE (THE RUSSIAN-AMERICAN GALLIUM SOLAR-NEUTRINO EXPERIMENT)
    ABDURASHITOV, JN
    FAIZOV, EL
    GAVRIN, VN
    GUSEV, AO
    KALIKHOV, AV
    KNODEL, TV
    KNYUSHENKO, II
    KORNOUKHOV, VN
    MIRMOV, IN
    PSHUKOV, AM
    SHALAGIN, AM
    SHIKHIN, AA
    TIMOFEYEV, PV
    VERETENKIN, EP
    VERMUL, VKM
    ZATSEPIN, GT
    BOWLES, TJ
    NICO, JS
    TEASDALE, WA
    WARK, DL
    WILKERSON, JF
    CLEVELAND, BT
    DAILY, T
    DAVIS, R
    LANDE, K
    LEE, CK
    WILDENHAIN, PW
    ELLIOTT, SR
    CHERRY, ML
    KOUZES, RT
    [J]. PHYSICS LETTERS B, 1994, 328 (1-2) : 234 - 248
  • [2] A NEW MEASUREMENT OF THE SPIN-DEPENDENT STRUCTURE-FUNCTION G(1)(X) OF THE DEUTERON
    ADAMS, D
    ADEVA, B
    ARIK, E
    ARVIDSON, A
    BADELEK, B
    BALLINTIJN, MK
    BARDIN, G
    BAUM, G
    BERGLUND, P
    BETEV, L
    BIRSA, R
    BJORKHOLM, P
    BONNER, BE
    DEBOTTON, N
    BRADAMANTE, F
    BRESSAN, A
    BULTMANN, S
    BURTIN, E
    CAVATA, C
    CLOCCHIATTI, M
    CRABB, D
    CRANSHAW, J
    CUHADAR, T
    DALLATORRE, S
    VANDANTZIG, R
    DESHPANDE, A
    DHAWAN, S
    DULYA, C
    DYRING, A
    EICHBLATT, S
    FASCHING, D
    FEINSTEIN, F
    FERNANDEZ, C
    FROIS, B
    GARZON, JA
    GIORGI, M
    VONGOELER, E
    GRACIA, G
    DECASSAGNAC, RG
    DEGROOT, N
    PERDEKAMP, MG
    GULMEZ, E
    VONHARRACH, D
    HASEGAWA, T
    HAUTLE, P
    HAYASHI, N
    HEUSCH, CA
    HORIKAWA, N
    HUGHES, VW
    IGO, G
    [J]. PHYSICS LETTERS B, 1995, 357 (1-2) : 248 - 254
  • [3] GALLEX RESULTS FROM THE 1ST 30 SOLAR-NEUTRINO RUNS
    ANSELMANN, P
    HAMPEL, W
    HEUSSER, G
    KIKO, J
    KIRSTEN, T
    LAUBENSTEIN, M
    PERNICKA, E
    PEZZONI, S
    RONN, U
    SANN, M
    SCHLOSSER, C
    WINK, R
    WOJCIK, M
    VONAMMON, R
    EBERT, KH
    FRITSCH, T
    HELLRIEGEL, K
    HENRICH, E
    STIEGLITZ, L
    WEIRICH, F
    BALATA, M
    FERRARI, N
    LALLA, H
    BELLOTTI, E
    CATTADORI, C
    CREMONESI, O
    FIORINI, E
    ZANOTTI, L
    ALTMANN, M
    VONFEILITZSCH, F
    MOSSBAUER, R
    SCHANDA, U
    BERTHOMIEU, G
    SCHATZMAN, E
    CARMI, I
    DOSTROVSKY, I
    BACCI, C
    BELLI, P
    BERNABEI, R
    DANGELO, S
    PAOLUZI, L
    BEVILACQUA, A
    CHARBIT, S
    CRIBIER, M
    GOSSET, L
    RICH, J
    SPIRO, M
    STOLARCZYK, T
    TAO, C
    VIGNAUD, D
    [J]. PHYSICS LETTERS B, 1994, 327 (3-4) : 377 - 385
  • [4] ARPESELLA C, 1992, BOREXINO PROPOSAL, V1
  • [5] ARPESELLA C, 1992, BOREXINO PROPOSAL, V2
  • [6] BAHCALL J, 1995, SOLAR MODELING
  • [7] Bahcall J.N., 1989, Neutrino Astrophysics
  • [8] SOLAR MODELS, NEUTRINO EXPERIMENTS, AND HELIOSEISMOLOGY
    BAHCALL, JN
    ULRICH, RK
    [J]. REVIEWS OF MODERN PHYSICS, 1988, 60 (02) : 297 - 372
  • [9] NEUTRAL-CURRENT REACTIONS OF SOLAR AND SUPERNOVA NEUTRINOS ON DEUTERIUM
    BAHCALL, JN
    KUBODERA, K
    NOZAWA, S
    [J]. PHYSICAL REVIEW D, 1988, 38 (04): : 1030 - 1039
  • [10] PREDICTIONS FOR A LIQUID ARGON SOLAR NEUTRINO DETECTOR
    BAHCALL, JN
    BALDOCEOLIN, M
    CLINE, DB
    RUBBIA, C
    [J]. PHYSICS LETTERS B, 1986, 178 (2-3) : 324 - 328