Safety of Transcranial Direct Current Stimulation: Evidence Based Update 2016

被引:1060
作者
Bikson, Marom [1 ]
Grossman, Pnina [1 ]
Thomas, Chris [1 ]
Zannou, Adantchede Louis [1 ]
Jiang, Jimmy [1 ]
Adnan, Tatheer [1 ]
Mourdoukoutas, Antonios P. [1 ]
Kronberg, Greg [1 ]
Truong, Dennis [1 ]
Boggio, Paulo [2 ,3 ]
Brunoni, Andre R. [4 ]
Charvet, Leigh [5 ]
Fregni, Felipe [6 ]
Fritsch, Brita [7 ,8 ]
Gillick, Bernadette [9 ]
Hamilton, Roy H. [10 ,11 ,12 ]
Hampstead, Benjamin M. [13 ,14 ]
Jankord, Ryan [15 ]
Kirton, Adam [16 ]
Knotkova, Helena [17 ,18 ]
Liebetanz, David [19 ]
Liu, Anli [20 ]
Loo, Colleen [21 ]
Nitsche, Michael A. [19 ,22 ,23 ]
Reis, Janine [7 ,8 ]
Richardson, Jessica D. [6 ,24 ,25 ]
Rotenberg, Alexander [26 ,27 ,28 ]
Turkeltaub, Peter E. [29 ,30 ]
Woods, Adam J. [31 ]
机构
[1] CUNY City Coll, Dept Biomed Engn, New York, NY 10031 USA
[2] Univ Prebiteriana Mackenzie, Ctr Hlth & Biol Sci, Cognit Neurosci Lab, Sao Paulo, Brazil
[3] Univ Prebiteriana Mackenzie, Ctr Hlth & Biol Sci, Dev Disorders Program, Sao Paulo, Brazil
[4] Univ Sao Paulo, Lab Neurosci LIM 27, Dept & Inst Psychiat, Serv Interdisciplinary Neuromodulat, Sao Paulo, Brazil
[5] NYU, Sch Med, Dept Neurol, NYU MS Comprehens Care Ctr, New York, NY USA
[6] Harvard Med Sch, Beth Israel Deaconess Med Ctr, Dept Neurol, Berenson Allen Ctr Noninvas Brain Stimulat, Boston, MA USA
[7] Univ Med Ctr, Dept Neurol, Freiburg, Germany
[8] Univ Freiburg, BrainLinks BrainTools Cluster Excellence, Freiburg, Germany
[9] Univ Minnesota, Sch Med, Dept Phys Med & Rehabil, Minneapolis, MN 55455 USA
[10] Univ Penn, Lab Cognit & Neural Stimulat, Philadelphia, PA 19104 USA
[11] Univ Penn, Ctr Cognit Neurosci, Philadelphia, PA 19104 USA
[12] Univ Penn, Dept Neurol, Philadelphia, PA 19104 USA
[13] VA Ann Arbor Healthcare Syst, Mental Hlth Serv, Ann Arbor, MI USA
[14] Univ Michigan, Dept Psychiat, Ann Arbor, MI 48109 USA
[15] US Air Force Res Lab, Appl Neurosci, 711th Human Performance Wing, Wright Patterson AFB, OH USA
[16] Univ Calgary, Cumming Sch Med, Dept Pediat & Clin Neurosci, Calgary, AB, Canada
[17] MJHS Inst Innovat Palliat Care, New York, NY USA
[18] Albert Einstein Coll Med, Dept Social & Family Med, Bronx, NY 10467 USA
[19] Univ Gottingen, Univ Med Ctr, Dept Clin Neurophysiol, D-37075 Gottingen, Germany
[20] NYU, Sch Med, NYU Comprehens Epilepsy Ctr, New York, NY USA
[21] Univ New S Wales, St George Hosp, Clin Acad, Psychiat,Black Dog Inst, Sydney, NSW, Australia
[22] TU Dortmund, Leibniz Res Ctr Working Environm & Human Factors, Dortmund, Germany
[23] Univ Med Hosp Bergmannsheil, Dept Neurol, Bochum, Germany
[24] Univ South Carolina, Dept Commun Sci & Disorders, Columbia, SC 29208 USA
[25] Univ New Mexico, Dept Speech & Hearing Sci, Albuquerque, NM 87131 USA
[26] Harvard Med Sch, Dept Neurol, Div Cognit Neurol, Berenson Allen Ctr Noninvas Brain Stimulat, Boston, MA USA
[27] Beth Israel Deaconess Med Ctr, Boston, MA 02215 USA
[28] Harvard Med Sch, Childrens Hosp Boston, Div Epilepsy & Neurophysiol, Pediat Neuromodulat Program,Dept Neurol, Boston, MA USA
[29] Georgetown Univ, Dept Neurol, Washington, DC USA
[30] MedStar Natl Rehabil Hosp, Div Res, Washington, DC USA
[31] Univ Florida, McKnight Brain Inst, Dept Aging & Geriatr Res, Ctr Cognit Aging & Memory,Inst Aging, Gainesville, FL USA
关键词
Safety; tDCS; Transcranial Direct Current Stimulation; Electrical stimulation; tDCS safety; Mood disorders; NONINVASIVE BRAIN-STIMULATION; MOTOR CORTEX PLASTICITY; ELECTRICAL-STIMULATION; MAGNETIC STIMULATION; HEALTHY-SUBJECTS; UPPER EXTREMITY; SINGLE SESSION; CEREBRAL-PALSY; OLDER-ADULTS; DOUBLE-BLIND;
D O I
10.1016/j.brs.2016.06.004
中图分类号
R74 [神经病学与精神病学];
学科分类号
100204 [神经病学];
摘要
This review updates and consolidates evidence on the safety of transcranial Direct Current Stimulation (tDCS). Safety is here operationally defined by, and limited to, the absence of evidence for a Serious Adverse Effect, the criteria for which are rigorously defined. This review adopts an evidence-based approach, based on an aggregation of experience from human trials, taking care not to confuse speculation on potential hazards or lack of data to refute such speculation with evidence for risk. Safety data from animal tests for tissue damage are reviewed with systematic consideration of translation to humans. Arbitrary safety considerations are avoided. Computational models are used to relate dose to brain exposure in humans and animals. We review relevant dose-response curves and dose metrics (e.g. current, duration, current density, charge, charge density) for meaningful safety standards. Special consideration is given to theoretically vulnerable populations including children and the elderly, subjects with mood disorders, epilepsy, stroke, implants, and home users. Evidence from relevant animal models indicates that brain injury by Direct Current Stimulation (DCS) occurs at predicted brain current densities (6.3-13 A/m(2)) that are over an order of magnitude above those produced by conventional tDCS. To date, the use of conventional tDCS protocols in human trials (<= 40 min, <= 4 milliamperes, <= 7.2 Coulombs) has not produced any reports of a Serious Adverse Effect or irreversible injury across over 33,200 sessions and 1000 subjects with repeated sessions. This includes a wide variety of subjects, including persons from potentially vulnerable populations. (C) 2016 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
引用
收藏
页码:641 / 661
页数:21
相关论文
共 188 条
[1]
Once- to Twice-Daily, 3-Year Domiciliary Maintenance Transcranial Direct Current Stimulation for Severe, Disabling, Clozapine-Refractory Continuous Auditory Hallucinations in Schizophrenia [J].
Andrade, Chittaranjan .
JOURNAL OF ECT, 2013, 29 (03) :239-242
[2]
Successful aging: Advancing the science of physical independence in older adults [J].
Anton, Stephen D. ;
Woods, Adam J. ;
Ashizawa, Tetso ;
Barb, Diana ;
Buford, Thomas W. ;
Carter, Christy S. ;
Clark, David J. ;
Cohen, Ronald A. ;
Corbett, Duane B. ;
Cruz-Almeida, Yenisel ;
Dotson, Vonetta ;
Ebner, Natalie ;
Efron, Philip A. ;
Fillingim, Roger B. ;
Foster, Thomas C. ;
Gundermann, David M. ;
Joseph, Anna-Maria ;
Karabetian, Christy ;
Leeuwenburgh, Christiaan ;
Manini, Todd M. ;
Marsiske, Michael ;
Mankowski, Robert T. ;
Mutchie, Heather L. ;
Perri, Michael G. ;
Ranka, Sanjay ;
Rashidi, Parisa ;
Sandesara, Bhanuprasad ;
Scarpace, Philip J. ;
Sibille, Kimberly T. ;
Solberg, Laurence M. ;
Someya, Shinichi ;
Uphold, Connie ;
Wohlgemuth, Stephanie ;
Wu, Samuel Shangwu ;
Pahor, Marco .
AGEING RESEARCH REVIEWS, 2015, 24 :304-327
[3]
Aree-uea Benchaporn, 2014, Journal of the Medical Association of Thailand, V97, P954
[4]
Induction of Hypomanic Episode With Transcranial Direct Current Stimulation [J].
Arul-Anandam, Abraham Patrick ;
Loo, Colleen ;
Mitchell, Philip .
JOURNAL OF ECT, 2010, 26 (01) :68-69
[5]
PSYCHOSOCIAL FUNCTION AND LIFE SATISFACTION AFTER STROKE [J].
ASTROM, M ;
ASPLUND, K ;
ASTROM, T .
STROKE, 1992, 23 (04) :527-531
[6]
Transcranial Direct Current Stimulation for Treatment of Refractory Childhood Focal Epilepsy [J].
Auvichayapat, Narong ;
Rotenberg, Alexander ;
Gersner, Roman ;
Ngodklang, Sudarat ;
Tiamkao, Somsak ;
Tassaneeyakul, Wichittra ;
Auvichayapat, Paradee .
BRAIN STIMULATION, 2013, 6 (04) :696-700
[7]
The Natural History of Depression up to 15 Years After Stroke The South London Stroke Register [J].
Ayerbe, Luis ;
Ayis, Salma ;
Crichton, Siobhan ;
Wolfe, Charles D. A. ;
Rudd, Anthony G. .
STROKE, 2013, 44 (04) :1105-+
[8]
Electrical Stimulation of the Cerebral Cortex Exerts Antiapoptotic, Angiogenic, and Anti-Inflammatory Effects in Ischemic Stroke Rats Through Phosphoinositide 3-Kinase/Akt Signaling Pathway [J].
Baba, Tanefumi ;
Kameda, Masahiro ;
Yasuhara, Takao ;
Morimoto, Takamasa ;
Kondo, Akihiko ;
Shingo, Tetsuro ;
Tajiri, Naoki ;
Wang, Feifei ;
Miyoshi, Yasuyuki ;
Borlongan, Cesario V. ;
Matsumae, Mitsunori ;
Date, Isao .
STROKE, 2009, 40 (11) :E598-E605
[9]
Hypomanic episode in unipolar depression during transcranial direct current stimulation [J].
Baccaro, Alessandra ;
Brunoni, Andre Russowsky ;
Bensenor, Isabela Martins ;
Fregni, Felipe .
ACTA NEUROPSYCHIATRICA, 2010, 22 (06) :316-318
[10]
Partially non-linear stimulation intensity-dependent effects of direct current stimulation on motor cortex excitability in humans [J].
Batsikadze, G. ;
Moliadze, V. ;
Paulus, W. ;
Kuo, M. -F. ;
Nitsche, M. A. .
JOURNAL OF PHYSIOLOGY-LONDON, 2013, 591 (07) :1987-2000