Structural alignment in similarity and difference judgments

被引:17
作者
Markman, AB
机构
[1] Columbia University, New York, NY
[2] Department of Psychology, Columbia University, 406 Schermerhorn Hall, New York
关键词
D O I
10.3758/BF03212423
中图分类号
B841 [心理学研究方法];
学科分类号
040201 ;
摘要
Similarity is a central construct in models of cognitive processing, and as such has been the focus of psychological inquiry. This work has revealed that similarity and difference judgments are not always inverses. One explanation for this effect is that similarity judgments focus on matching relations between the items, while difference judgments focus on the mismatching attributes. A second explanation is that both similarity and difference judgments involve a process of structural alignment, and that they use the output of this process differently. These views are contrasted by using the one-shot mapping technique that places attribute similarity and relational similarity in competition. The results suggest that similarity and difference judgments both involve structural alignment.
引用
收藏
页码:227 / 230
页数:4
相关论文
共 18 条
[1]   THE ROLES OF SIMILARITY IN TRANSFER - SEPARATING RETRIEVABILITY FROM INFERENTIAL SOUNDNESS [J].
GENTNER, D ;
RATTERMANN, MJ ;
FORBUS, KD .
COGNITIVE PSYCHOLOGY, 1993, 25 (04) :524-575
[2]   THE MECHANISMS OF ANALOGICAL LEARNING [J].
GENTNER, D .
SIMILARITY AND ANALOGICAL REASONING, 1989, :199-241
[3]   STRUCTURE-MAPPING - A THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK FOR ANALOGY [J].
GENTNER, D .
COGNITIVE SCIENCE, 1983, 7 (02) :155-170
[4]   STRUCTURAL ALIGNMENT IN COMPARISON - NO DIFFERENCE WITHOUT SIMILARITY [J].
GENTNER, D ;
MARKMAN, AB .
PSYCHOLOGICAL SCIENCE, 1994, 5 (03) :152-158
[5]   SYSTEMATICITY AND SURFACE SIMILARITY IN THE DEVELOPMENT OF ANALOGY [J].
GENTNER, D ;
TOUPIN, C .
COGNITIVE SCIENCE, 1986, 10 (03) :277-300
[6]   RELATIONAL SIMILARITY AND THE NONINDEPENDENCE OF FEATURES IN SIMILARITY JUDGMENTS [J].
GOLDSTONE, RL ;
MEDIN, DL ;
GENTNER, D .
COGNITIVE PSYCHOLOGY, 1991, 23 (02) :222-262
[7]   SIMILARITY, INTERACTIVE ACTIVATION, AND MAPPING [J].
GOLDSTONE, RL .
JOURNAL OF EXPERIMENTAL PSYCHOLOGY-LEARNING MEMORY AND COGNITION, 1994, 20 (01) :3-27
[8]  
Holyoak K. J., 1995, MENTAL LEAPS
[9]   TOWARD AN INSTANCE THEORY OF AUTOMATIZATION [J].
LOGAN, GD .
PSYCHOLOGICAL REVIEW, 1988, 95 (04) :492-527
[10]   STRUCTURAL ALIGNMENT DURING SIMILARITY COMPARISONS [J].
MARKMAN, AB ;
GENTNER, D .
COGNITIVE PSYCHOLOGY, 1993, 25 (04) :431-467