A critical review of the use of pseudorelative permeabilities for upscaling

The properties and limitations of different dynamic pseudorelative permeability methods are summarized. Severe difficulties common to all methods are discussed: choosing the number and locations of the coarse-grid rock types, defining the simulations from which the pseudos are generated, and the dependence of the pseudos on well rates and positions. It is concluded that, in practice, pseudos cannot be used reliably to scale up from a ''fine-grid'' geological model to a ''coarse-grid'' fluid-flow model except for cases where capillary or gravity equilibrium can be assumed at the coarse-gridblock scale. Scaling up from the core scale to the geological model is more likely to be possible because capillary forces are more important at smaller scales. A practical approach to the dynamic upscaling problem is outlined, but one should not expect that the effects of the detail in the geological model will be captured more than qualitatively.