The differential symptom determinants of the Holmes' masked (M) and U1 strains of tobacco mosaic virus previously were mapped to the 5'-coterminal open reading frame (ORF) encoding the 126-kDa protein and the N-terminal two-thirds of the 183-kDa protein. Both proteins influence viral RNA accumulation, but the function of, and impact on, symptom formation by large domains within the 126-kDa gene, which are not conserved with sequences in analogous ORFs from other related viruses, are unknown. In the current study, cDNA clones representing each strain (i.e,, M(IC)-TMV and UI-TMV) were mutated in these nonconserved domains to further define the nucleotides responsible for mosaic symptom induction on Nicotiana tabacum. Progeny virus of a mutant containing only eight nucleotide substitutions from the M(IC)-TMV sequence to the U1-TMV sequence within the 126-kDa protein ORF of M(IC)-TMV induced U1-TMV-like symptoms. Single or multiple substitutions among these eight nucleotides further defined residues critical for symptom modulation. Complementary substitutions in the M(IC)-TMV and U1-TMV sequences did not always yield progeny virus that induced complementary visual symptoms. Progeny of some mutants contained second-site spontaneous mutations at specific positions shown to influence symptom phenotype. For a subset of the stable site-directed mutants, there was no correlation between severity of systemic symptoms and chlorotic lesion size or virus accumulation in these chlorotic lesions on inoculated leaves. (C) 1996 Academic Press, Inc