Effects of fathead minnow colonization and removal on a prairie wetland ecosystem

Fish communities in prairie wetlands are extremely dynamic. Due to complete winterkills and periodic colonization, individual basins alternate between supporting a fish population and being fishless. Here we assess the ecological consequences of colonization and subsequent extinction of a fathead minnow population in a prairie wetland. We used a BACI-type approach (before-after control impact) in which data from the colonized wetland were paired with data from a similar fishless site first when both wetlands were fishless (1996), then when the minnow population reached moderate densities in the colonized site (1998), and then again when the colonized site became fishless after treatment with rotenone (1999). Fish colonization resulted in significant increases in turbidity, total phosphorus, and chlorophyll a in the water column; it also caused significant decreases in the abundance of aquatic insects and large cladocerans. Elimination of the minnow population largely reversed the effects of minnow colonization. Our results indicate that characteristics of prairie wetlands can vary as they alternate between supporting fathead minnow populations and being fishless and that ecological characteristics may change rapidly in response to minnow colonization or elimination.