Surveillance biopsies are superior to functional studies for the diagnosis of acute and chronic renal allograft pathology in children

In this report of our 3-yr protocol biopsy program, we describe the evolution of acute rejection (AR) and chronic renal allograft nephropathy (CAN) in a cohort of 21 children treated with antibody induction, tacrolimus, mycophenolate mofetil, and prednisone. The aims of this study were to compare the pathogenicity of clinical acute rejection (CAR) and subclinical acute rejection (SAR), and to determine whether functional studies accurately represent acute and chronic renal allograft pathology in pediatric recipients with disproportionately large grafts. Using concurrent biopsies, we evaluated: (1) the utility of changes in the baseline sCr (DeltasCr) to predict both the onset of AR and the response to immunosuppressive therapy; and (ii) the relationship of the calculated creatinine clearance and the presence of pathologic proteinuria to the severity of CAN. We performed 112 biopsies: I I donor, 73 protocol, 16 acute graft dysfunction and 121-month follow-up AR therapy. CAR and SAR were similar in incidence, timing and histologic severity. Progression of CAN was associated with the first episode of CAR (p < 0.02) and the cumulative number of episodes of CAR (p < 0.01), SAR (p < 0.05), CAR plus SAR (p < 0.002) and borderline SAR (B-SAR) (p < 0.006). One-month post-treatment DeltasCrs could not distinguish 1-month follow-up biopsies with histologically confirmed worsened or unchanged AR from those with improved histology (35.2 +/- 74.8% vs. 23.8 +/- 24.9%, p = NS). These findings led to the addition of anti-lymphocyte antibody therapy in five of 10 (50%) cases. Despite 100% 3-yr actuarial graft survival and excellent function (GFR = 111 36 mL/min/1.73 m(2)), 18 of 21 (86%) patients had grade I CAN or greater chronic histology at a mean +/- SD follow-up period of 18.2 +/- 13.1 months. Thirteen of 21 (62%) patients progressed to grade I CAN at 5.2 +/- 3.6 months and five (38%) of these patients progressed to grade 11 CAN at 17.8 +/- 11.3 months. Schwartz GFR did not differ between patients with or without CAN (108 +/- 38 mL/min/1.73 m(2) vs. 127 +/- 8 mL/min/1.73 in, p NS). In biopsies with CAN and no associated AR, neither the Banff chronic tubulointerstitial (Banff ci) score nor the Banff chronic grade correlated with the GFR. Proteinuria was not associated with CAN. Clinical AR and SAR are similar histologic lesions with a capacity for CAN progression. In pediatric renal transplant recipients, longitudinal protocol biopsies are superior to functional studies for the diagnosis and post-therapeutic monitoring of AR and for the surveillance of AN.