The nicotinic pharmacophore: Thermodynamics of the hydrogen-bonding complexation of nicotine, nornicotine, and models

The thermodynamics of the hydrogen-bonding complexation of the acetylcholine agonists nicotine and nornicotine and of model pyridines, pyrrolidines, and N-methylpyrrolidines has been measured in CCI4 by FTIR spectrometry toward a reference hydrogen-bond donor, 4-fluorophenol. Various methods are devised for measuring separately the hydrogen-bond acceptor strength of each nitrogen of nicotine and nornicotine: variation of the stoichiometry of complexation; correlations with electrostatic potentials on nitrogens and with substituent constants in the series of 3-substituted pyridines, 2-substituted pyrrolidines, and 2-substituted N-methylpyrrolidines; and linear free energy relationships between 4-fluorophenol and hydrogen fluoride hydrogen-bonded complexes. It is consistently found that nicotine and nornicotine have two active hydrogen-bond acceptor sites, the pyridine and pyrrolidine nitrogens, and that ca. 90% (for nicotine) and 80% (for nornicotine) of the 1:1 hydrogen-bonded complexes are formed to the pyridine nitrogen, although the pyrrolidine nitrogen is the first protonation site of nicotine and nornicotine in water. The low hydrogen-bond basicity of the pyrrolidine nitrogen in nicotine is mainly explained by the inductive electron-withdrawing and steric effects of the 2-(3-pyridyl) substituent. The partition of the Gibbs energy of the isomerism of complexation (AH...Nsp(2) = F AH..NSp(3)) into enthalpic and entropic contributions shows that the selectivity in favor of the pyridine nitrogen is driven by entropy. It is important to recognize the bifunctionality of nicotine in hydrogen bonding for understanding its lipophilicity and molecular recognition in non protonic media. When monoprotonated on their sp(3) nitrogen, nicotine and nornicotine keep, through their sp(2) nitrogen, a significant hydrogen-bond basicity which is greater than that of the ester group of acetylcholine.