17 beta-Estradiol metabolism by hamster hepatic microsomes: Comparison of catechol estrogen O-methylation with catechol estrogen oxidation and glutathione conjugation

Catechol estrogens, the cytochromes P450 mediated metabolites of 17 beta-estradiol, undergo further metabolism either via catechol O-methyltransferase (COMT) catalyzed methylation, or by oxidation and subsequent thioether formation with glutathione (GSH). Secondary metabolites of 17 beta-estradiol arising from both these metabolic pathways have been identified in vivo. However, the relative contribution of catechol O-methylation, and catechol oxidation followed by GSH conjugation, to the disposition of the catechol estrogens is unclear. We have therefore quantified both pathways of catechol estrogen disposition, generated in situ from 17 beta-estradiol, in hamster hepatic microsomes. 17 beta-Estradiol was readily converted to 2- and 4-hydroxy-17 beta-estradiol, both of which were effectively methylated in the presence of COMT (300 units/mL). Addition of GSH (50 mu M-1 mM) to microsomal incubations resulted in the formation of four catechol estrogen-derived GSH conjugates. Three conjugates of 2-hydroxy-17 beta-estradiol were identified: 2-hydroxy-1,4-bis(glutathion-S-yl)-17 beta-estradiol, 2-hydroxy-1-glutathion-S-yl-17 beta-estradiol, and 2-hydroxy-4-glutathion-S-yl-17 beta-estradiol. In contrast, just one GSH conjugate of 4-hydroxy-17 beta-estradiol was identified: 4-hydroxy-1-glutathion-S-yl-17 beta-estradiol. When a combination of COMT and GSH were simultaneously added to microsomal incubations, both metabolic pathways competed for the same pool of catechol estrogens, and ascorbate dramatically influenced which of these two pathways predominate. In the presence of ascorbate, catechol estrogen methylation predominated over catechol estrogen oxidation and GSH conjugation. In the absence of ascorbic acid, catechol estrogen methylation, and catechol estrogen oxidation linked to GSH conjugation, contributed equally to the disposition of the catechol estrogens. 17 beta-Estradiol 2- and 4-hydroxylase activity was always higher in the absence of ascorbate, irrespective of whether GSH or COMT was used as the trapping agent. Thus, the usual method (COMT plus ascorbate) of determining 17 beta-estradiol 2- and 4-hydroxylase activity underestimates enzyme activity by similar to 50% when compared to the value obtained when GSH is used to trap the o-quinones in the absence of ascorbate. A reassessment of 17 beta-estradiol 2- and 4-hydroxylase activity in different species and tissues is required to permit a more informed evaluation of the role of catechol estrogens in estrogen-induced carcinogenesis.