Political Economy, Ecological Modernization, and Energy Use: A Panel Analysis of State-Level Energy Use in the United States, 1960-1990

The present study will examine energy consumption from two competing perspectives within environmental social science: political economy and ecological modernization. These frameworks will be evaluated with a fixed-effects panel analysis of state-level energy use between the years 1960 and 1990, based on data for 50 states plus Washington, DC, from the Energy Information Administration's State Energy Data System. The results from the panel analysis show that the increase in total energy use between 1960 and 1990 depended on both increasing economic growth and urbanization, even after controlling for population size, industrialization, and inflation-adjusted energy prices. The results challenge the claims of ecological modernization theory and support a political economic approach to the study of changes in energy use. In the conclusion, the study's findings will be framed within the context of the early twenty-first-century economic and ecological crises. In light of efforts to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, this study can also further advance the renewable energy debate by reminding us of the social drivers of energy use.