A molecular dynamics study of small water clusters comparing two flexible models for water

We report results from a molecular dynamics study of small water clusters, (H2O)(n=2,3,4,6,8,) comparing the recent polarizable, dissociable (PD) model of Halley et al. with the central force Stillinger-Rahman (SR) model. Dynamics calculations in the microcanonical ensemble quantified short-time averaged temperatures and RMS bond length fluctuations, which, in combination with simulated thermal quenching, identified structures and structural and phase changes of the clusters. Both models generally pointed to similar global minimum energy configurations, but local minima configurations, relative energies, and RMS bond length fluctuations varied more significantly. The PD model, with its incorporation of many-body effects, more accurately reproduced the structural features of clusters predicted from ab initio calculations, although it over-estimated the binding energies. Solid-like, pre-melting, and liquid-like states were identified based upon RMS bond length fluctuations for the O-O, O-H and H-H pairs. The SR and PD models yielded very similar trends in melting temperature as a function of cluster size. This suggests that general trends in the melting phenomenon do not depend strongly upon details of the models. The melting temperatures for the dimer and tetramer closely resembled the bulk melting temperature, while those for other sizes were considerably lower.