The purpose of this study was to determine the acute effects of doxorubicin and its less cardiotoxic epimer, 4'-epirubicin, on the contractile response of isolated myocytes, and to assess similarities or differences with respect to active oxygen-derived mechanisms. Calcium-tolerant myocytes from rat ventricle were field stimulated at 1.0 Hz, and the maximum extent of cell shortening, peak shortening velocity, and peak relaxation velocity of single twitches were measured by video edge detection. The contractile responses of the myocytes to the two anthracyclines were approximately equal. Exposure of the cells to 10 mu M of either anthracycline for 20 min decreased all indices of contractility by 28% (p < 0.05). The active oxygen scavengers, superoxide dismutase and catalase, distinguished the extent to which active oxygen was involved in modifying cellular contractility. Paradoxically, superoxide dismutase done (10 U/mL) decreased contractility by 21%. Nevertheless, superoxide dismutase (10 U/mL) prevented the decreases in contractility produced by doxorubicin. In contrast, superoxide dismutase only mildly (32%) protected against 4'-epirubicin. Catalase (10 U/mL), however, provided substantial (82-93%) protection against both anthracyclines. Hydrogen peroxide therefore, and presumably hydroxyl radicals, were involved in mediating the decreases in contractility from both doxorubicin and 4'-epirubicin. These results show that an acute exposure to clinically relevant concentrations of these anthracyclines significantly depresses myocyte contractility and that, in this respect, 4'-epirubicin is as potentially cardiotoxic as doxorubicin. The results with antioxidant enzymes also strongly support a free radical mechanism for the toxicity of doxorubicin and 4'-epirubicin to cardiomyocytes.