Should the stagnant homeownership rate be a source of concern?

The homeownership rate in the United States was essentially stagnant during the 1980s. This stagnation should be a source of concern if the rate reflects stagnant economic conditions and ownership opportunities; not if it simply reflects changing demographic conditions or preferences. Using a series of affordability measures, we find that homeownership opportunities improved almost everywhere during the 1980s, suggesting that the cause of the stagnant rate was something other than economic conditions. In fact, we found that both demographics and changes in preferences led to an increase in the proportion of households headed by single people; all else being equal, this would tend to push the owner-occupancy rate downward. We also found that, while homeownership opportunities improved during the 1980s, the ex ante user cost of owning a home increased almost everywhere, reducing the financial attractiveness of owning a home. The combination of improving affordability conditions and worsening financial appeal had an overall neutral effect on the aggregate ownership rate.