Acyclovir with and without prednisone for the treatment of herpes zoster - A randomized, placebo-controlled trial

被引:264
作者
Whitley, RJ
Weiss, H
Gnann, JW
Tyring, S
Mertz, GJ
Pappas, PG
Schleupner, CJ
Hayden, F
Wolf, J
Soong, SJ
Laughlin, C
Gnann, J
Sherrill, L
Pappas, P
Greenberg, S
Couch, R
Wolfe, J
Basler, E
Orengo, I
Liu, HC
Pollard, R
Savoia, M
Oxman, MN
Fine, D
Mangi, R
Kessler, H
Peacock, J
Tilles, J
Flowers, F
Beutner, K
机构
[1] NIAID, NIH, BETHESDA, MD 20892 USA
[2] UNIV ALABAMA, DEPT PEDIAT, CENT UNIT, BIRMINGHAM, AL 35233 USA
[3] BAYLOR COLL MED, HOUSTON, TX 77030 USA
[4] UNIV KANSAS, KANSAS CITY, KS USA
[5] UNIV CALIF SAN DIEGO, SAN DIEGO, CA 92103 USA
[6] UNIV OKLAHOMA, OKLAHOMA CITY, OK USA
[7] HOSP ST RAPHAEL, NEW HAVEN, CT USA
[8] RUSH PRESBYTERIAN ST LUKES MED CTR, CHICAGO, IL USA
[9] WAKE FOREST UNIV, WINSTON SALEM, NC 27109 USA
[10] UNIV CALIF IRVINE, IRVINE, CA 92717 USA
[11] UNIV FLORIDA, GAINESVILLE, FL USA
[12] SOLANO DERMATOL, SOLANO BEACH, CA USA
[13] BURROUGHS WELLCOME CO, RES TRIANGLE PK, NC 27709 USA
[14] INFECT DIS RES, FAIRFAX, VA USA
[15] HENNEPIN CTY MED CTR, MINNEAPOLIS, MN USA
[16] UNIV ALABAMA, DEPT MICROBIOL, BIRMINGHAM, AL 35233 USA
[17] UNIV ALABAMA, DEPT MED, BIRMINGHAM, AL 35233 USA
[18] UNIV ALABAMA, CTR COMPREHENS CANC, BIRMINGHAM, AL 35294 USA
[19] UNIV TEXAS, MED BRANCH, DEPT MICROBIOL, GALVESTON, TX 77550 USA
[20] UNIV NEW MEXICO, SCH MED, ALBUQUERQUE, NM 87131 USA
[21] UNIV VIRGINIA, SALEM, VA 24153 USA
[22] VET AFFAIRS MED CTR, SALEM, VA 24153 USA
[23] UNIV VIRGINIA, MED CTR, CHARLOTTESVILLE, VA 22908 USA
关键词
D O I
10.7326/0003-4819-125-5-199609010-00004
中图分类号
R5 [内科学];
学科分类号
1002 ; 100201 ;
摘要
Objective: To determine the effect of acyclovir and prednisone treatment of herpes tester on chronic pain and quality-of-life outcomes. Design: Randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled study with a 2 x 2 factorial design. Setting: 15 university hospitals or affiliated clinics. Patients: 208 immunocompetent patients older than 50 years of age who had localized herpes tester that developed less than 72 hours before study enrollment. Intervention: Acyclovir or a matched placebo was administered orally, 800 mg five times daily, for 21 days. Prednisone or a matched placebo was administered orally at 60 mg/d for the first 7 days, 30 mg/d for days 8 to 14, and 15 mg/d for days 15 to 21. The four treatments regimens given were acyclovir plus prednisone; acyclovir plus prednisone placebo; prednisone plus acyclovir placebo; and placebos for both acyclovir and prednisone. Measurements: Patients were monitored daily for the first 28 days for lesion healing, resolution of pain, return to usual activity, and return to uninterrupted sleep. Monitoring was then done monthly for 6 months. Patients documented analgesic requirements each day, and adverse events and laboratory abnormalities were recorded at each clinic visit. An intention-to-treat analysis was used. Results: Patients were randomly allocated to receive one of the four regimens. Demographic characteristics were similar for each group. Time to total crusting and healing was accelerated for patients receiving acyclovir plus prednisone compared with patients receiving two placebos; the risk ratios were 2.27 (95% CI, 1.46 to 3.55) for total crusting and 2.07 (Cl, 1.26 to 3.38) for healing. Similarly, compared with the placebo group, patients receiving acyclovir plus prednisone had accelerated time to cessation of acute neuritis (risk ratio, 3.02 [Cl, 1.42 to 6.41]), time to return to uninterrupted sleep (risk ratio, 2.12 [Cl, 1.25 to 3.58]); time to return to usual daily activity (risk ratio, 3.22 [Cl, 1.92 to 5.40]); and time to cessation of analgesic therapy (risk ratio, 3.15 [Cl, 1.69 to 5.89]). In the acyclovir plus prednisone group, resolution of pain during the 6 months after disease onset did not statistically differ from that in the other groups. No important clinical or laboratory adverse events occurred in any group. Conclusions: In relatively healthy persons older than 50 years of age who have localized herpes tester, combined acyclovir and prednisone therapy can improve quality of life.
引用
收藏
页码:376 / 383
页数:8
相关论文
共 20 条
[1]   TREATMENT OF HERPES ZOSTER WITH ACTH [J].
APPELMAN, DH .
NEW ENGLAND JOURNAL OF MEDICINE, 1955, 253 (16) :693-695
[2]   PREVENTION OF POSTHERPETIC NEURALGIA - EVALUATION OF TREATMENT WITH ORAL PREDNISONE, ORAL ACYCLOVIR, AND RADIOTHERAPY [J].
BENOLDI, D ;
MIRIZZI, S ;
ZUCCHI, A ;
ALLEGRA, F .
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF DERMATOLOGY, 1991, 30 (04) :288-290
[3]   VALACICLOVIR COMPARED WITH ACYCLOVIR FOR IMPROVED THERAPY FOR HERPES-ZOSTER IN IMMUNOCOMPETENT ADULTS [J].
BEUTNER, KR ;
FRIEDMAN, DJ ;
FORSZPANIAK, C ;
ANDERSEN, PL ;
WOOD, MJ .
ANTIMICROBIAL AGENTS AND CHEMOTHERAPY, 1995, 39 (07) :1546-1553
[4]   ACTH VERSUS PREDNISONE AND PLACEBO IN HERPES-ZOSTER TREATMENT [J].
CLEMMENSEN, OJ ;
ANDERSEN, KE .
CLINICAL AND EXPERIMENTAL DERMATOLOGY, 1984, 9 (06) :557-563
[5]   FAMCICLOVIR, A NEW ORAL ANTIHERPES DRUG - RESULTS OF THE FIRST CONTROLLED CLINICAL-STUDY DEMONSTRATING ITS EFFICACY AND SAFETY IN THE TREATMENT OF UNCOMPLICATED HERPES-ZOSTER IN IMMUNOCOMPETENT PATIENTS [J].
DEGREEF, H ;
ANDREJEVIC, L ;
AOKI, F ;
AREND, J ;
ASHTON, R ;
DEBACKER, W ;
BARTLETT, K ;
VANBLOKLAND, WB ;
BISHOP, S ;
BOON, R ;
BORBUJO, J ;
CALZ, AM ;
CANDAELE, M ;
COLLINS, P ;
CRAWFORD, G ;
CVIJETIC, O ;
DECROIX, J ;
DECUYPER, C ;
DELESCLUSE, J ;
DEMAUBEUGE, J ;
DUSCHET, P ;
FRANSEN, H ;
FRENK, E ;
FRITSCH, P ;
GHEERAERT, P ;
GOETIJN, M ;
GONZALEZ, A ;
GOOSSEN, J ;
GRCIC, R ;
GRIFFIN, D ;
GSCHNAIT, F ;
HANSSENS, Y ;
HARMS, M ;
HOSANG, M ;
ILIC, V ;
ISENBERG, Y ;
JANSEN, A ;
JONES, S ;
JOVOVIC, D ;
KRAFFT, T ;
KRANENDONK, H ;
LALOSEVIC, J ;
LEEN, C ;
MARCIAS, M ;
MCGOUGALL, B ;
MCKENDRICK, M ;
MILOJEVIC, M ;
NABER, F ;
NELEMANS, F ;
NYE, F .
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF ANTIMICROBIAL AGENTS, 1994, 4 (04) :241-246
[6]   EFFECTS OF EARLY CORTICOSTEROID THERAPY ON SKIN ERUPTION AND PAIN OF HERPES ZOSTER [J].
EAGLSTEIN, WH ;
KATZ, R ;
BROWN, JA .
JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN MEDICAL ASSOCIATION, 1970, 211 (10) :1681-+
[7]  
ELLIOTT FA, 1964, LANCET, V2, P610
[8]  
ESMANN V, 1987, LANCET, V2, P126
[9]  
GELFAND ML, 1954, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V154, P911
[10]  
GILL KS, 1994, EXPT OPINIONS INVEST, V3, P791