Coal fly ash- and copper smelter dust-induced modulation of ex vivo production of tumor necrosis factor-alpha by murine macrophages: Effects of metals and overload

The objective of this study was to assess the effect of two arsenic-containing particles, coal fly ash (FA) and copper smelter dust (CU), on lung integrity and on the ex vivo release of tumor necrosis factor alpha (TNF-alpha) by alveolar phagocytes. Particle effects were compared in nonoverload condition on the basis of a low but identical volume load and arsenic content intratracheally instilled in the mouse lung (273 nl/mouse and 186 ng arsenic/mouse; FA(L) and CUL groups). Other mice received 600 ng arsenic/mouse in amounts of particles leading to different volume loads (FA(H) and CUH groups: 880 and 273 nl/mouse, respectively). Animals were sacrificed at 1, 6, 30, or 120 d (FA(L) and CUL groups) or at 6 and 120 d posttreatment (FA(H) and CUH groups). Biochemical markers and inflammatory cell number and type were analyzed in bronchoalveolar lavage, ex vivo TNF-alpha production by alveolar phagocytes was assessed, and measurement of arsenic lung content and histopathological examinations were performed. Our results show that coal fly ash and copper smelter dust bear distinct inflammatory properties. At the end of the observation period (d 120), the high CU dose (CUH) produced a fibrotic reaction whereas the high dose of FA particles (FA(H)) generated a delayed and persistent lung inflammatory reaction associated with lymphoid noduli. Marked differences in TNF-alpha production were observed within the CU and FA groups. CU particles, conceivably through their metal content, decreased TNF-alpha production by alveolar phagocytes. Due to their low arsenic content, considerably higher FA particle doses needed to be administered to produce an inhibition of TNF-alpha production. Since high doses of FA (FA(H)) caused an overload condition, our results do not allow vs to decide whether FA-mediated TNF-alpha reduction is due to the load administered or to the metallic content.