A prospective, randomized, and controlled study of fluid management in children with severe head injury: Lactated Ringer's solution versus hypertonic saline

Objectives: Resuscitation in severe head injury may be detrimental when given with hypotonic fluids. We evaluated the effects of lactated Ringer's solution (sodium 131 mmol/L, 277 mOsm/L) compared with hypertonic saline (sodium 268 mmol/L, 598 mOsm/L) in severely head-injured children over the first 3 days after injury. Design: An open, randomized, and prospective study. Setting: A 16-bed pediatric intensive care unit (ICU) (level III) at a university children's hospital. Patients: A total of 35 consecutive children with head injury. Interventions: Thirty-two children with Glasgow Coma Scores of <8 were randomly assigned to receive either lactated Ringer's solution (group I) or hypertonic saline (group 2). Routine care was standardized, and included the following: head positioning at 30 degrees; normothermia (96.8 degrees to 98.6 degrees F [36 degrees to 37 degrees C]); analgesia and sedation with morphine (10 to 30 mu g/kg/hr), midazolam (0.2 to 0.3 mg/kg/hr), and phenobarbital; volume controlled ventilation (Paco(2), of 26.3 to 30 torr [3.5 to 4 kPa]); and optimal oxygenation (Pao(2) of 90 to 105 torr [12 to 14 kPa], oxygen saturation of >92%, and hematocrit of >0.30). Measurements and Main Results: Mean arterial pressure and intracranial pressure (ICP) were monitored continuously and documented hourly and at every intervention. The means of every 4 hr period were calculated and serum sodium concentrations were measured at the same time. An ICP of 15 mm Hg was treated with a predefined sequence of interventions, and complications were documented. There was no difference with respect to age, male/female ratio, or initial Glasgow Coma Score. In both groups, there was an inverse correlation between serum sodium concentration and ICP (group 1: r=-.13, r(2) =.02, p<.03; group 2: r =-.29, r(2) =.08, p<.001) that disappeared in group 1 and increased in group 2 (group 1: r = -.08, r(2) =.01, NS; group 2: r = -.35, r(2) =.12, p<.001). Correlation between serum sodium concentration and cerebral perfusion pressure (CPP) became significant in group 2 after 8 hrs of treatment (r =.2, r(2) =.04, P =.002). Over time, ICP and CPP did not significantly differ between the groups. However, to keep ICP at <15 mm Hg, group 2 patients required significantly fewer interventions (p <.02). Group 1 patients received less sodium (8.0 +/- 4.5 vs. 11.5 +/- 5.0 mmol/kg/day, p =.05) and more fluid on day 1 (2850 +/- 1480 vs. 2180 +/- 770 mL/m(2), p =.05). They also had a higher frequency of acute respiratory distress syndrome (four vs. 0 patients, p =.1) and more than two complications (six vs. 1 patient, p =.09). Group 2 patients had significantly shorter ICU stay times (11.6 +/- 6.1 vs. 8.0 +/- 2.4 days; p=.04) and shorter mechanical ventilation times (9.5 +/- 6.0 vs. 6.9 +/- 2.2 days; p =.1). The survival rate and duration of hospital stay were similar in both groups. Conclusions: Treatment of severe head injury with hypertonic saline is superior to that treatment with lactated Ringer's solution. An increase in serum sodium concentrations significantly correlates with lower ICP and higher CPP. Children treated with hy pertonic saline require fewer interventions, have fewer complications, and stay a shorter time in the ICU.