On uncertainties in cross-correlation lags and the reality of wavelength-dependent continuum lags in active galactic nuclei

被引:525
作者
Peterson, BM
Wanders, I
Horne, K
Collier, S
Alexander, T
Kaspi, S
Maoz, D
机构
[1] Ohio State Univ, Dept Astron, Columbus, OH 43210 USA
[2] Univ St Andrews, Sch Phys & Astron, St Andrews KY16 9SS, Fife, Scotland
[3] Inst Adv Study, Princeton, NJ 08540 USA
[4] Tel Aviv Univ, Sch Phys & Astron, IL-69978 Tel Aviv, Israel
[5] Tel Aviv Univ, Wise Observ, IL-69978 Tel Aviv, Israel
关键词
D O I
10.1086/316177
中图分类号
P1 [天文学];
学科分类号
0704 ;
摘要
We describe a model-independent method of assessing the uncertainties in cross-correlation lags determined from the light curves of active galactic nuclei (AGNs) and use this method to investigate the reality of lags between UV and optical continuum variations in well-studied AGNs. Our results confirm the existence of such lags in NGC 7469, We find that the continuum variations at 1825, 4845, and 6962 Angstrom follow those at 1315 Angstrom by 0.22(-0.13)(+0.12), 1.25(-0.35)(+0.48), and 1.84(-0.94)(+0.93) days, respectively, based on the centroids of the cross-correlation functions; the error intervals quoted correspond to 68% confidence levels, and each of these lags is greater than zero at no less than 97% confidence. We do not iind statistically significant interband continuum lags in NGC 5548, NGC 3783, or Fairall 9. Wavelength-dependent continuum lags may be marginally detected in the case of NGC 4151. However, on the basis of theoretical considerations, wavelength-dependent continuum lags in sources other than NGC 7469 are not expected to have been detectable in previous experiments. We also confirm the existence of a statistically significant lag between X-ray and UV continuum variations in the blazer PKS 2155 - 304.
引用
收藏
页码:660 / 670
页数:11
相关论文
共 35 条
  • [1] Alexander T, 1997, ASTROPHYS SPACE SC L, V218, P163
  • [2] REVERBERATION MAPPING OF THE EMISSION-LINE REGIONS OF SEYFERT-GALAXIES AND QUASARS
    BLANDFORD, RD
    MCKEE, CF
    [J]. ASTROPHYSICAL JOURNAL, 1982, 255 (02) : 419 - 439
  • [3] BRINKMANN W, 1994, ASTRON ASTROPHYS, V288, P433
  • [4] STEPS TOWARD DETERMINATION OF THE SIZE AND STRUCTURE OF THE BROAD-LINE REGION IN ACTIVE GALACTIC NUCLEI .1. AN 8 MONTH CAMPAIGN OF MONITORING NGC-5548 WITH IUE
    CLAVEL, J
    REICHERT, GA
    ALLOIN, D
    CRENSHAW, DM
    KRISS, G
    KROLIK, JH
    MALKAN, MA
    NETZER, H
    PETERSON, BM
    WAMSTEKER, W
    ALTAMORE, A
    BARIBAUD, T
    BARR, P
    BECK, S
    BINETTE, L
    BROMAGE, GE
    BROSCH, N
    DIAZ, AI
    FILIPPENKO, AV
    FRICKE, K
    GASKELL, CM
    GIOMMI, P
    GLASS, IS
    GONDHALEKAR, P
    HACKNEY, RL
    HALPERN, JP
    HUTTER, DJ
    JORSATER, S
    KINNEY, AL
    KOLLATSCHNY, W
    KORATKAR, A
    KORISTA, KT
    LAOR, A
    LASOTA, JP
    LEIBOWITZ, E
    MAOZ, D
    MARTIN, PG
    MAZEH, T
    MEURS, EJA
    NAIR, AD
    OBRIEN, P
    PELAT, D
    PEREZ, E
    PEROLA, GC
    PTAK, RL
    RODRIGUEZPASCUAL, P
    ROSENBLATT, EI
    SADUN, AC
    SANTOSLLEO, M
    SHAW, RA
    [J]. ASTROPHYSICAL JOURNAL, 1991, 366 (01) : 64 - 81
  • [5] COLLIER SJ, 1998, IN PRESS APJ
  • [6] MULTIWAVELENGTH MONITORING OF THE BL LACERTAE OBJECT PKS 2155-304 .3. GROUND-BASED OBSERVATIONS IN 1991 NOVEMBER
    COURVOISIER, TJL
    BLECHA, A
    BOUCHET, P
    BRATSCHI, P
    CARINI, MT
    DONAHUE, M
    EDELSON, R
    FEIGELSON, ED
    FILIPPENKO, AV
    GLASS, IS
    HEIDT, J
    KOLLGAARD, RI
    MATHESON, T
    MILLER, HR
    NOBLE, JC
    SEKIGUCHI, K
    SMITH, PS
    URRAY, CM
    WAGNER, SJ
    [J]. ASTROPHYSICAL JOURNAL, 1995, 438 (01) : 108 - 119
  • [7] Multiwavelength observations of short-timescale variability in NGC 4151 .1. Ultraviolet observations
    Crenshaw, DM
    RodriguezPascual, PM
    Penton, SV
    Edelson, RA
    Alloin, D
    Ayres, TR
    Clavel, J
    Horne, K
    Johnson, WN
    Kaspi, S
    Korista, KT
    Kriss, GA
    Krolik, JH
    Malkan, MA
    Maoz, D
    Netzer, H
    OBrien, PT
    Peterson, BM
    Reichert, GA
    Shull, JM
    Ulrich, MH
    Wamsteker, W
    Warwick, RS
    Yaqoob, T
    Balonek, TJ
    Barr, P
    Bromage, GE
    Carini, M
    Carone, TE
    Cheng, FZ
    Chuvaev, KK
    Dietrich, M
    Doroshenko, VT
    DultzinHacyan, D
    Filippenko, AV
    Gaskell, CM
    Glass, IS
    Goad, MR
    Hutchings, J
    Kazanas, D
    Kollatschny, W
    Koratkar, AP
    Laor, A
    Leighly, K
    Lyutyi, VM
    MacAlpine, GM
    Malkov, YF
    Martin, PG
    McCollum, B
    Merkulova, NI
    [J]. ASTROPHYSICAL JOURNAL, 1996, 470 (01) : 322 - 335
  • [8] MULTIWAVELENGTH MONITORING OF THE BL LACERTAE OBJECT PKS 2155-304 .4. MULTIWAVELENGTH ANALYSIS
    EDELSON, R
    KROLIK, J
    MADEJSKI, G
    MARASCHI, L
    PIKE, G
    URRY, CM
    BRINKMANN, W
    COURVOISIER, TJL
    ELLITHORPE, J
    HORNE, K
    TREVES, A
    WAGNER, S
    WAMSTEKER, W
    WARWICK, R
    ALLER, HD
    ALLER, MF
    ASHLEY, M
    BLECHA, A
    BOUCHET, P
    BRATSCHI, P
    BREGMAN, JN
    CARINI, M
    CELOTTI, A
    DONAHUE, M
    FEIGELSON, E
    FILIPPENKO, AV
    FINK, H
    GEORGE, I
    GLASS, I
    HEIDT, J
    HEWITT, J
    HUGHES, P
    KOLLGAARD, R
    KONDO, Y
    KORATKAR, A
    LEIGHLY, K
    MARSCHER, A
    MARTIN, PG
    MATHESON, T
    MILLER, HR
    KNOBLE, JC
    OBRIEN, P
    PIAN, E
    REICHERT, G
    SAKEN, JM
    SHULL, JM
    SITKO, M
    SMITH, PS
    SUN, WH
    TAGLIAFERRI, G
    [J]. ASTROPHYSICAL JOURNAL, 1995, 438 (01) : 120 - 134
  • [9] THE DISCRETE CORRELATION-FUNCTION - A NEW METHOD FOR ANALYZING UNEVENLY SAMPLED VARIABILITY DATA
    EDELSON, RA
    KROLIK, JH
    [J]. ASTROPHYSICAL JOURNAL, 1988, 333 (02) : 646 - 659
  • [10] Multiwavelength observations of short-timescale variability in NGC 4151 .4. Analysis of multiwavelength continuum variability
    Edelson, RA
    Alexander, T
    Crenshaw, DM
    Kaspi, S
    Malkan, MA
    Peterson, BM
    Warwick, RS
    Clavel, J
    Filippenko, AV
    Horne, K
    Korista, KT
    Kriss, GA
    Krolik, JH
    Maoz, D
    Nandra, K
    OBrien, PT
    Penton, SV
    Yaqoob, T
    Albrecht, P
    Alloin, D
    Ayres, TR
    Balonek, TJ
    Barr, P
    Barth, AJ
    Bertram, R
    Bromage, GE
    Carini, M
    Carone, TE
    Cheng, FZ
    Chuvaev, KK
    Dietrich, M
    DultzinHacyan, D
    Gaskell, CM
    Glass, IS
    Goad, MR
    Hemar, S
    Ho, LC
    Huchra, JP
    Hutchings, J
    Johnson, WN
    Kazanas, D
    Kollatschny, W
    Koratkar, AP
    Kovo, O
    Laor, A
    MacAlpine, GM
    Magdziarz, P
    Martin, PG
    Matheson, T
    McCollum, B
    [J]. ASTROPHYSICAL JOURNAL, 1996, 470 (01) : 364 - 377