A marginal likelihood approach for estimating penetrance from kin-cohort designs

The kin-cohort design is a promising alternative to traditional cohort or case-control designs for estimating penetrance of an identified rare autosomal mutation. In this design, a suitably selected sample of participants provides genotype and detailed family history information on the disease of interest. To estimate penetrance of the mutation, we consider a marginal likelihood approach that is computationally simple to implement, more flexible than the original analytic approach proposed by Wacholder et al. (1998, American Journal of Epidemiology 148, 623-629), and more robust than the likelihood approach considered by Call et al. (1999, Genetic Epidemiology 16, 15-39) to presence of residual familial correlation We study the trade-off between robustness and efficiency using simulation experiments. The method is illustrated by analysis of the data from the Washington Ashkenazi Study.