Reliability of radiographic grading of osteoarthritis of the hip and knee

被引:66
作者
Sun, Y [1 ]
Gunther, KP [1 ]
Brenner, H [1 ]
机构
[1] UNIV ULM,DEPT ORTHOPAED,D-89081 ULM,GERMANY
关键词
osteoarthritis; radiographic grading; reliability;
D O I
10.3109/03009749709065675
中图分类号
R5 [内科学];
学科分类号
1002 [临床医学]; 100201 [内科学];
摘要
We review studies on the reliability of radiographic assessment of osteoarthritis of the hip and knee. Reliability studies were reported for 10 among 24 identified scores. In general, moderate to good agreement was found for overall scores and for separate grading of joint space narrowing of the hip and osteophytes of the knee in the majority of studies, while reliability tended to be lower for other radiographic features. Overall scores of the knee were more reliable than overall scores of the hip, and intra-rater-reliability was considerably higher than inter-rater-reliability in most instances. Comparison of reliability between scores can only be made with caution, given the difference in the design of reliability studies, particularly the different qualification of involved observers. The limits of existing knowledge on reliability of commonly used radiologic scores are outlined, and, proposals are made to overcome those limits in future studies.
引用
收藏
页码:155 / 165
页数:11
相关论文
共 38 条
[1]
Altman DG, 1990, PRACTICAL STAT MED R
[2]
RADIOGRAPHIC ASSESSMENT OF PROGRESSION IN OSTEOARTHRITIS [J].
ALTMAN, RD ;
FRIES, JF ;
BLOCH, DA ;
CARSTENS, J ;
COOKE, D ;
GENANT, H ;
GOFTON, P ;
GROTH, H ;
MCSHANE, DJ ;
MURPHY, WA ;
SHARP, JT ;
SPITZ, P ;
WILLIAMS, CA ;
WOLFE, F .
ARTHRITIS AND RHEUMATISM, 1987, 30 (11) :1214-1225
[3]
BAGGE E, 1992, RHEUMATOL INT, V12, P33
[4]
INTRACLASS CORRELATION COEFFICIENT AS A MEASURE OF RELIABILITY [J].
BARTKO, JJ .
PSYCHOLOGICAL REPORTS, 1966, 19 (01) :3-&
[5]
BRANDT KD, 1991, ARTHRITIS RHEUM, V34, P1381
[6]
BULL U, 1986, RADIOLOGIE, V2, P354
[7]
Burnett S.J., 1994, A radiographic atlas of osteoarthritis
[8]
THE CHIARI PELVIC OSTEOTOMY - A REVIEW OF THE LONG-TERM RESULTS [J].
CALVERT, PT ;
AUGUST, AC ;
ALBERT, JS ;
KEMP, HB ;
CATTERALL, A .
JOURNAL OF BONE AND JOINT SURGERY-BRITISH VOLUME, 1987, 69 (04) :551-555
[9]
DECREASED SURVIVAL WITH INCREASING PREVALENCE OF FULL-BODY, RADIOGRAPHICALLY DEFINED OSTEOARTHRITIS IN WOMEN [J].
CERHAN, JR ;
WALLACE, RB ;
ELKHOURY, GY ;
MOORE, TE ;
LONG, CR .
AMERICAN JOURNAL OF EPIDEMIOLOGY, 1995, 141 (03) :225-234
[10]
Cerhan JR, 1996, J RHEUMATOL, V23, P1565