The 33-kDa extrinsic subunit of PSII stabilizes the O-2-evolving tetranuclear Mn cluster and accelerates O-2 evolution. We have used site-directed mutagenesis to replace one or both Cys residues in spinach MSP with Ala. Previous experiments using native and reduced MSP led to the conclusion that a disulfide bridge between these two cysteines is essential both for its binding and its functional properties. We report here that the disulfide bridge, though essential for MSP stability, is otherwise dispensible. The mutation C51A by itself had a delayed effect on MSP function: [C51A]MSP restored normal rates of O-2 evolution to PSII but was defective in stabilizing this activity during extended illumination. In contrast, the Cys-free double mutant, [C28A,C51A]MSP, was functionally identical to the wild-type protein. Based on results presented here, we propose a light-dependent interaction between MSP and PSII that occurs only during the redox cycling of the Mn cluster and which is destabilized by the single mutation, C51A.