Comparative analysis of baseline 8-oxo-7,8-dihydroguanine in mammalian cell DNA, by different methods in different laboratories:: an approach to consensus

被引：169

作者：

Collins, A ^{[1
]}

Gedik, C ^{[1
]}

Vaughan, N ^{[1
]}

Wood, S ^{[1
]}

White, A ^{[1
]}

Dubois, J ^{[1
]}

Duez, P ^{[1
]}

Dehon, G ^{[1
]}

Rees, JF ^{[1
]}

Loft, S ^{[1
]}

Moller, P ^{[1
]}

Poulsen, H ^{[1
]}

Riis, B ^{[1
]}

Weimann, A ^{[1
]}

Cadet, J ^{[1
]}

Douki, T ^{[1
]}

Ravanat, JL ^{[1
]}

Sauvaigo, S ^{[1
]}

Faure, H ^{[1
]}

Morel, I ^{[1
]}

Morin, B ^{[1
]}

Epe, B ^{[1
]}

Phoa, N ^{[1
]}

Hartwig, A ^{[1
]}

Pelzer, A ^{[1
]}

Dolara, P ^{[1
]}

Casalini, C ^{[1
]}

Giovannelli, L ^{[1
]}

Lodovici, M ^{[1
]}

Olinski, R ^{[1
]}

Bialkowski, K ^{[1
]}

Foksinski, M ^{[1
]}

Gackowski, D ^{[1
]}

Duracková, Z ^{[1
]}

Hlinciková, L ^{[1
]}

Korytar, P ^{[1
]}

Sivonová, M ^{[1
]}

Dusinská, M ^{[1
]}

Mislanová, C ^{[1
]}

Viña, J ^{[1
]}

Lloret, A ^{[1
]}

Möller, L ^{[1
]}

Hofer, T ^{[1
]}

Nygren, J ^{[1
]}

Gremaud, E ^{[1
]}

Herbert, K ^{[1
]}

Chauhan, D ^{[1
]}

Kelly, F ^{[1
]}

Dunster, C ^{[1
]}

Lunec, J ^{[1
]}

机构：

[1] Rowett Res Inst, Bucksburn AB21 9SB, Aberdeen, Scotland

来源：

CARCINOGENESIS | 2002年 / 23卷 / 12期

关键词：

D O I：

10.1093/carcin/23.12.2129

中图分类号：

R73 [肿瘤学];

学科分类号：

100214 ;

摘要：

The European Standards Committee on Oxidative DNA Damage (ESCODD) was set up to resolve the problems associated with the measurement of background levels of oxidative DNA damage (in particular 8-oxo-7,8-dihydroguanine, or 8-oxoGua) in human cells. A tendency for DNA oxidation to occur during sample preparation prior to chromatography has been recognized as the source of a very substantial artefact. To assess the success of attempts to eliminate the artefact, ESCODD has distributed to its members standard samples of pig liver and HeLa cells for analysis. Estimates of 8-oxoGua in pig liver, using chromatographic techniques, ranged from 2.23 to 441 per 10(6) guanines, with a median of 10.47 per 10(6) guanines. Chromatographic analysis of HeLa cell DNA gave a range of 1.84 to 214 per 10(6) guanines with a median of 5.23 per 10(6) guanines. HeLa cell DNA was also analysed by an enzymic approach, in which whole cell DNA was treated with formamidopyrimidine DNA glycosylase, which nicks DNA at sites of 8-oxoGua, and the breaks measured with the comet assay, alkaline unwinding or alkaline elution. Values with these methods ranged from 0.06 to 4.98 8-oxoGua per 10(6) guanines, with a median of 0.79 per 10(6) guanines. Although there are clearly still serious discrepancies between methods and laboratories, the lowest estimates by chromatography (arguably those in which the artefact was best controlled) are only 2.5 times higher than the median value obtained with the enzymic approach.

引用

页码：2129 / 2133

页数：5

共 17 条

[1] A simpler, more robust method for the analysis of 8-oxoguanine in DNA
Beckman, KB
Saljoughi, S
Mashiyama, ST
Ames, BN
[J]. FREE RADICAL BIOLOGY AND MEDICINE, 2000, 29 (3-4) : 357 - 367
[2] Inverse correlation between alcohol consumption and lymphocyte levels of 8-hydroxydeoxyguanosine in humans
Bianchini, F
Jaeckel, A
Vineis, P
Martinez-Garciá, C
Elmstahl, S
van Kappel, AL
Boeing, H
Ohshima, H
Riboli, E
Kaaks, R
[J]. CARCINOGENESIS, 2001, 22 (06) : 885 - 890
[3] Problems in the measurement of 8-oxoguanine in human DNA. Report of a workshop, DNA Oxidation, held in Aberdeen, UK, 19-21 January, 1997
Collins, A
Cadet, J
Epe, B
Gedik, C
[J]. CARCINOGENESIS, 1997, 18 (09) : 1833 - 1836
[4] Oxidative DNA damage in human cells: The influence of antioxidants and DNA repair
Collins, AR
Duthie, SJ
Fillion, L
Gedik, CM
Vaughan, N
Wood, SG
[J]. BIOCHEMICAL SOCIETY TRANSACTIONS, 1997, 25 (01) : 326 - 331
[5] Comparison of different methods of measuring 8-oxoguanine as a marker of oxidative DNA damage
Collins, AR
Brown, J
Bogdanov, M
Cadet, J
Cooke, M
Douki, T
Dunster, C
Eakins, J
Epe, B
Evans, M
Farmer, P
Gedik, CM
Halliwell, B
Herbert, K
Hofer, T
Hutchinson, R
Jenner, A
Jones, GDD
Kasai, H
Kelly, F
Lloret, A
Loft, S
Lunec, J
McEwan, M
Möller, L
Olinski, R
Podmore, I
Poulsen, H
Ravanat, JL
Rees, JF
Reetz, F
Shertzer, H
Spiegelhalder, B
Turesky, R
Tyrrell, R
Viña, J
Vinicombe, D
Weimann, A
de Wergifosse, B
Wood, SG
[J]. FREE RADICAL RESEARCH, 2000, 32 (04) : 333 - 341
[6] Inter-laboratory validation of procedures for measuring 8-oxo-7,8-dihydroguanine/8-oxo-7,8-dihydro-2′-deoxyguanosine in DNA
Collins, AR
Gedik, C
Wood, S
White, A
Dubois, J
Duez, P
Rees, JF
Legall, R
Degand, L
Loft, S
Jensen, A
Poulsen, H
Weimann, A
Jensen, BR
Cadet, J
Douki, T
Ravanat, JL
Faure, H
Tripier, M
Morel, I
Sergent, O
Cillard, P
Morin, B
Epe, B
Phoa, N
Hartwig, A
Pelzer, A
Dolara, P
Casalini, C
Guglielmi, F
Luceri, C
Kasai, H
Kido, R
Olinski, R
Bialkowski, K
Duracková, Z
Hlinciková, L
Korytar, P
Dusinská, M
Mislanová, C
Viña, J
Lloret, A
Möller, L
Hofer, T
Gremaud, E
Fay, L
Stadler, R
Eakins, J
Pognan, F
O'Brien, J
[J]. FREE RADICAL RESEARCH, 2002, 36 (03) : 239 - 245
[7] Oxidative damage to DNA: Do we have a reliable biomarker?
Collins, AR
Dusinska, M
Gedik, CM
Stetina, R
[J]. ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH PERSPECTIVES, 1996, 104 : 465 - 469
[8] Measuring oxidative damage to DNA; HPLC and the comet assay compared
Gedik, CM
Wood, SG
Collins, AR
[J]. FREE RADICAL RESEARCH, 1998, 29 (06) : 609 - 615
[9] Sensitive analysis of oxidative DNA damage in mammalian cells: Use of the bacterial Fpg protein in combination with alkaline unwinding
Hartwig, A
Dally, H
Schlepegrell, R
[J]. TOXICOLOGY LETTERS, 1996, 88 (1-3) : 85 - 90
[10] Reduction of oxidation during the preparation of DNA and analysis of 8-hydroxy-2′-deoxyguanosine
Hofer, T
Moller, L
[J]. CHEMICAL RESEARCH IN TOXICOLOGY, 1998, 11 (08) : 882 - 887

← 1 2 →