Cytogenetic status pre-transplant as a predictor of outcome post bone marrow transplantation for chronic myelogenous leukaemia

We have analysed pre-transplant cytogenetic findings in 418 patients with CML in pre-blastic phase who underwent allogeneic BMT between February 1981 and January 1998, Five different patient groups were identified: A = Philadelphia (Ph)+; B = Ph-, BCR-ABL+; C = variant Ph (VPh); D = Ph chromosome plus at least one of: trisomy 8, +Ph, chromosome 17 abnormalities and E = other abnormalities in addition to the Ph chromosome. There were two principal conclusions, Firstly, Ph- patients showed a better outcome, and VPh patients a worse outcome, than those with a standard Ph, both in terms of leukaemia-free survival (LFS) (76.9%, 22.1% and 31.9%) and the risk of treatment failure relative to those with a standard Ph (relative risks of 0.49 and 1.92, respectively). One contributing factor may be relapse: no Ph- patients relapsed, whereas all other groups showed similar probabilities of relapse at 5 years (range 33.0-44.0%), Secondly, those with the additional changes of +8, +Ph and i(17q) did not show a worse outcome than those with no additional changes (5 year survival of 44.7% vs 51.8%; 5 year LFS of 40.6% vs 31.9%), whereas those with other additional changes may fare worst of all (40.4% and 16.0%, respectively).