Post hoc analysis: Use and dangers in perspective

被引:28
作者
Elliott, HL
机构
关键词
post hoc analysis; hypothesis; case-control studies; meta analysis;
D O I
10.1097/00004872-199609002-00006
中图分类号
R6 [外科学];
学科分类号
1002 ; 100210 ;
摘要
Dangers and advantages of post hoc analysis Post hoc analysis is of major importance in the generation of hypotheses. However, the hypothesis is created by the analysis and has not been proved by any 'experiment'. In some circumstances the conclusion derived from a post hoc analysis is entirely appropriate. For example, it was the only method used by Crick and Watson for determining the structure of DNA. In other circumstances, however, the results will be misleading. Need for caution with interpretation The results of a post hoc analysis should be viewed with considerable scepticism and, in advance of confirmation by other appropriately de signed prospective studies, should not be regarded as definitive proof.
引用
收藏
页码:S21 / S24
页数:4
相关论文
共 25 条
[1]  
[Anonymous], 1991, JAMA, V265, P3255
[2]  
[Anonymous], 1980, LANCET, V1, P1261
[3]  
Aursnes Vvar I. Litleskare, 1995, Blood Pressure, V4, P157, DOI 10.3109/08037059509077588
[4]   DISCORDANCE BETWEEN METAANALYSES AND LARGE-SCALE RANDOMIZED, CONTROLLED TRIALS - EXAMPLES FROM THE MANAGEMENT OF ACUTE MYOCARDIAL-INFARCTION [J].
BORZAK, S ;
RIDKER, PM .
ANNALS OF INTERNAL MEDICINE, 1995, 123 (11) :873-877
[5]   BLOOD-PRESSURE, STROKE, AND CORONARY HEART-DISEASE .2. SHORT-TERM REDUCTIONS IN BLOOD-PRESSURE - OVERVIEW OF RANDOMIZED DRUG TRIALS IN THEIR EPIDEMIOLOGIC CONTEXT [J].
COLLINS, R ;
PETO, R ;
MACMAHON, S ;
HEBERT, P ;
FIEBACH, NH ;
EBERLEIN, KA ;
GODWIN, J ;
QIZILBASH, N ;
TAYLOR, JO ;
HENNEKENS, CH .
LANCET, 1990, 335 (8693) :827-838
[6]  
COLLINS R, 1995, LANCET, V345, P669
[7]   RANDOMIZED TRIAL OF TREATMENT OF HYPERTENSION IN ELDERLY PATIENTS IN PRIMARY CARE [J].
COOPE, J ;
WARRENDER, TS .
BRITISH MEDICAL JOURNAL, 1986, 293 (6555) :1145-1151
[8]   STOP-HYPERTENSION - SWEDISH TRIAL IN OLD PATIENTS WITH HYPERTENSION [J].
DAHLOF, B ;
HANSSON, L ;
LINDHOLM, L ;
RASTAM, L ;
SCHERSTEN, B ;
WESTER, PO .
JOURNAL OF HYPERTENSION, 1986, 4 (04) :511-513
[9]   SAFETY OF CALCIUM-ANTAGONISTS [J].
ELLIOTT, HL ;
EPSTEIN, M ;
HALLER, H ;
MANCIA, G .
LANCET, 1995, 346 (8987) :1421-1421
[10]   Advantages and disadvantages of the meta-analysis approach [J].
Fagard, RH ;
Staessen, JA ;
Thijs, L .
JOURNAL OF HYPERTENSION, 1996, 14 :S9-S12