Contrasting membrane localization and behavior of halogenated cyclobutanes that follow or violate the Meyer-Overton hypothesis of general anesthetic potency

The membrane localization and properties of two halogenated cyclobutanes were examined using H-2 and F-19 NMR. The common predictors of potency indicate that these two compounds will have anesthetic activity; however, 1,2-dichlorohexafluorocyclobutane (c(CClFCClFCF2CF2)) is not an effective anesthetic, whereas 1-chloro-1,2,2-trifluorocyclobutane (c(CClFCF2CH2CH2)) is an effective general anesthetic. Using H-2 NMR, the effect of these compounds on the acyl chain packing in palmitoyl (d(31)) oleoylphosphatidylcholine membranes was examined. The addition of the anesthetic c(CClFCF2CH2CH2) results in small increases in the segmental order near the headgroup, whereas segments deeper in the bilayer show decreases in order. These results are consistent with those obtained previously for halothane, isoflurane, and enflurane. On the addition of the nonanesthetic c(CClFCClFCF2CF2), the segmental order is virtually unchanged, except for a slightly changed order near the segments 10-12 of the palmitoyl chains. These results, and the F-19 chemical shifts, indicate that the anesthetic c(CClFCF2CH2CH2) exhibits a preference for the membrane interface, as do the other general anesthetics, whereas the nonanesthetic c(CClFCClFCF2CF2) resides within the membrane hydrocarbon core. The compound c(CClFCClFCF2CF2) and other nonanesthetic halocarbons have lower molecular dipole moments compared to effective anesthetic halocarbons, which may account for their altered distribution within the membrane. These data strongly suggest that preferential localization of a halocarbon within the membrane interface is a predictor of anesthetic potency. Furthermore, the data indicate that the properties and forces in the membrane interface deserve consideration as mediators of anesthetic activity.