Multicenter evaluation of the Bayer VERSANT™ HIV-1 RNA 3.0 assay:: analytical and clinical performance

Background: The use of quantitative HIV-1 RNA assays is part of the standard of care for the management of HIV-1-infected individuals. Objective: The Bayer VERSANT(TM) HIV-1 RNA 3.0 Assay (bDNA) was evaluated for reproducibility, linearity, limits of detection and quantitation, effects of potentially interfering substances and conditions, effects of plasma collection and handling conditions, clinical sensitivity and specificity, and biologic variability. Study design: Anti-HIV-1-positive specimens, patient specimens containing potentially interfering substances, and anti-HIV-negative specimens were collected from several HIV clinics, blood centers, or commercial companies across the United States. Specimen panels used to evaluate nonclinical performance of the assay were prepared at Bayer Diagnostics. Bayer Assay Development personnel performed two of the nonclinical studies-effect of freeze-thaw cycles using `spiked' HIV-1 RNA-positive samples and effect of other disease organisms. All other studies were conducted at seven external sites. In some of the studies performed, specimens were tested in parallel with the Roche AMPLICOR(R) HIV-1 MONITOR(TM) version 1.0 PCR test. Results /conclusions: The results of these studies showed that the Bayer Assay has excellent reproducibility, a broad linear range (75-500,000 HIV-1 RNA copies/ml), throughput of 168 patient results per two-plate run in a 22-h period, and few limitations for use. Because this test is designed for use only in individuals who are known to be HIV-1-positive, the clinical specificity of 97.6% is adequate for its intended use. These characteristics make it an attractive method for general laboratory use of monitoring HIV-1-infected patients. (C) 2002 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.