A retrospective study of surgical and conservative treatment for spinal extradural abscess

The management of spinal extradural abscess (SEA), particularly the choice between surgical and conservative treatment, is controversial. We therefore undertook a retrospective study of patients admitted with this diagnosis: Details of presentation, treatment and outcome were obtained by review of inpatient notes and radiology. Twenty-five individuals with SEA aged 10-79 years were admitted between 1989 and 1995. Nine were treated non-operatively with antibiotics, of which three also underwent diagnostic CT-guided biopsy, and 16 underwent surgical drainage. There was no significant difference in the neurological features at presentation between the two groups. Two patients (8%) died; 11 (44%) patients remained the same and 12 (48%) improved following treatment. Four patients treated conservatively (44%) and seven treated surgically (43%) were capable of return to work or school, whilst a further seven patients (three treated conservatively and four treated surgically) were able to lead independent lives. No significant difference in outcome was demonstrated between patients treated non-operatively and those treated surgically. We conclude that certain carefully selected patients can be treat-ed conservatively, but that surgery should remain the mainstay of management.