Interindexer consistency in PsycINFO

Reports results of a study to examine interindexer consistency (the degree to which indexers, when assigning terms to a chosen record, will choose the same terms to reflect that record) in the PsycINFO database using 60 records that were inadvertently processed twice between 1996 and 1998, Five aspects of interindexer consistency were analysed. Two methods were used to calculate interindexer consistency: one posited by Hooper (1965) and the other by Rollin (1981). Aspects analysed were: checktag consistency (66.24% using Hooper's calculation and 77.17% using Rollin's); major-to-all term consistency (49.02% and 62.59% respectively); overall indexing consistency (49.02% and 63.32%); classification code consistency (44.17% and 45.00%); and major-to-major term consistency (43.24%) and 56.09%), The average consistency across all categories was 50.4% using Hooper's method and 60.83% using Rollin's, Although comparison with previous studies is difficult due to methodological variations in the overall study of indexing consistency and the specific characteristics of: the database, results generally support previous findings when trends and similar studies are analysed.