Prospective audits with newer antiepileptic drugs in focal epilepsy: Insights into population responses?

Despite the availability of a wide range of new antiepileptic drugs (AEDs), there is little evidence that their introduction has substantially altered outcomes. This paper reviews data from 5 consecutive prospective audits with new AEDs using similar methodology. Prospective audits with topiramate (TPM; n = 135), levetiracetam(LEV; n = 136), zonisamide (ZNS; n = 141), pregabalin (PGB; n = 135), and lacosamide (LCM; n = 160) were undertaken in treated patients with uncontrolled partial-onset seizures. Follow-up continued until one of four end-points was reached: seizure freedom for >= 6 months on unchanged dosing; >= 50% reduction (responder) in seizure frequency on the highest tolerated dose compared with baseline; < 50% seizure frequency reduction (marginal response) compared with baseline in patients wishing to continue treatment with the new AED; or withdrawal due to lack of efficacy, side effects, or both. A greater proportion of seizure-free patients occurred with LEV (23.5%), LCM (21.9%), and TPM (20.7%) than with ZNS (12.8%) and PGB (10.4%). A higher percentage discontinued treatment with ZNS (41.8%) and PGB (50.4%) than with LEV (32.4%), TPM (31.1%), and LCM (22.5%). Most seizure-free patients responded to the new agent as first or second add-on (TPM 96%; LEV 97%; ZNS 89%; PGB 86%; LCM 97%) often at modest or moderate dosing (TPM 68%, <= 200 mg/day; LEV 63%, <= 1000 mg/day; ZNS 61%, <= 100 mg/day; PGB 86%, <= 300 mg/day; LCM 74%, <= 200 mg/day). With < 10% of patients discontinuing all AEDs due to lack of efficacy, tolerability was the major factor influencing the number of patients remaining on treatment. Lacosamide was the best (77% patients continued treatment), while PGB was the worst (50% continued treatment) tolerated AED. Overall, seizure freedom was achieved in < 25% of patients in each audit, mainly as a first or second add-on, with best tolerated AEDs producing a higher number of good outcomes. Seizures in very few patients with drug-resistant epilepsy, as defined by the International League Against Epilepsy task force, responded to any of the 5 newer AEDs. These data support the suggestion that the introduction of modern agents has not importantly impacted the outcomes in refractory epilepsy. (C) 2013 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.