Surgical management of pseudophakic retinal detachments - A meta-analysis

被引:61
作者
Arya, Adarsh V.
Emerson, John W.
Engelbert, Michael
Hagedorn, Curtis L.
Adelman, Ron A.
机构
[1] Yale Univ, Ctr Eye, Retina Serv, New Haven, CT USA
[2] Yale Univ, Dept Stat, New Haven, CT USA
[3] Columbia Univ, Coll Phys & Surg, Edward S Harkness Eye Inst, New York, NY USA
关键词
D O I
10.1016/j.ophtha.2006.05.044
中图分类号
R77 [眼科学];
学科分类号
100212 ;
摘要
Purpose: To compare the success of pars plana vitrectomy (PPV) versus scleral buckle (SB) in the management of uncomplicated pseudophakic retinal detachments (RDs). Design: Meta-analysis of published studies from 1966 to 2004 regarding surgical treatment of pseudophakic RDs. Participants: Two thousand two hundred thirty eyes: 1579 operated by SIB, 457 by PPV, and 194 by the combined method of PPV and SB. Methods: We compared reattachment and functional success rates after 3 commonly practiced surgical interventions for pseudophakic RDs: PPV, SB, and the combined method. Twelve hundred thirty-two articles were retrieved from Medline and by cross-reference searches. Articles with sufficient data on preoperative evaluation, applied surgical technique, and anatomical and functional success rates were included in this analysis. Articles regarding complex pseudophakic RDs, treatment by laser or pneumatic retinopexy, studies with indistinguishable treatment outcomes from phakic and pseudophakic RDs, or reviews without original data were excluded. Main Outcome Measures: Anatomical success rates after initial surgical intervention and after reoperation(s) for primary failures, and best or final visual outcome at the end of follow-up. Results: Of 1232 papers, 29 matched inclusion criteria. After controlling for variation between study characteristics, PPV and the combined method resulted in higher initial reattachment rates (odds ratio [OR], 1.69; 95% confidence interval [Cl], 1.07-2.68, and OR, 3.54; 95% Cl, 1.57-7.97, respectively) as compared with SIB. The differences between the procedures persisted for final reattachment outcome despite reoperation for primary failures. Final visual outcome also was found to depend on the choice of primary surgical intervention. After controlling for differences in the study characteristics, the probability of visual improvement was higher after PPV (OR, 2.34; 95% Cl, 1.58-3.46) or the combined method (OR, 11.52; 95% Cl, 4.42-30.04) as compared with SB. Conclusions: A meta-analysis of published literature implies that PPV with or without SB is more likely to achieve a favorable anatomical and visual outcome than conventional SB alone in uncomplicated pseudophakic RDs. However, the inherent limitations of differing study protocols, quality of included studies, and publication bias in a pooled analysis should be recognized.
引用
收藏
页码:1724 / 1733
页数:10
相关论文
共 48 条
[1]   Trends in vitreoretinal surgery at a tertiary referral centre: 1987 to 1996 [J].
Ah-Fat, FG ;
Sharma, MC ;
Majid, MA ;
McGalliard, JN ;
Wong, D .
BRITISH JOURNAL OF OPHTHALMOLOGY, 1999, 83 (04) :396-398
[2]   Primary vitrectomy for pseudophakic retinal detachment [J].
BartzSchmidt, KU ;
Kirchhof, B ;
Heimann, K .
BRITISH JOURNAL OF OPHTHALMOLOGY, 1996, 80 (04) :346-349
[3]   Retinal detachment after phacoemulsification cataract extraction [J].
Boberg-Ans, G ;
Villumsen, J ;
Henning, V .
JOURNAL OF CATARACT AND REFRACTIVE SURGERY, 2003, 29 (07) :1333-1338
[4]   Episcleral buckle or vitrectomy for the primary treatment of pseudophakic retinal detachment. A comparison of the two techniques [J].
Bovey, EH ;
Gonvers, M ;
Sahli, O .
KLINISCHE MONATSBLATTER FUR AUGENHEILKUNDE, 1998, 212 (05) :314-317
[5]  
Brazitikos P D, 2000, Semin Ophthalmol, V15, P65
[6]   Primary vitrectomy with perfluoro-n-octane use in the treatment of pseudophakic retinal detachment with undetected retinal breaks [J].
Brazitikos, PD ;
D'Amico, DJ ;
Tsinopoulos, IT ;
Stangos, NT .
RETINA-THE JOURNAL OF RETINAL AND VITREOUS DISEASES, 1999, 19 (02) :103-109
[7]   Pars plana vitrectomy without scleral buckle for pseudophakic retinal detachments [J].
Campo, RV ;
Sipperley, JO ;
Sneed, SR ;
Park, DW ;
Dugel, PU ;
Jacobsen, J ;
Flindall, RJ .
OPHTHALMOLOGY, 1999, 106 (09) :1811-1815
[8]  
CHAMBERS JM, 1983, GRAPHICAL METHODS DA, P567
[9]  
COUSINS S, 1986, OPHTHALMOLOGY, V93, P1198
[10]   RETINAL TEARS AND DETACHMENTS AFTER EXTRACAPSULAR CATARACT-SURGERY [J].
DAVISON, JA .
JOURNAL OF CATARACT AND REFRACTIVE SURGERY, 1988, 14 (06) :624-632