Intraspecific variation in the strength of density dependence in aphid populations

1. Experimental evidence is presented for positive, negative, and no density dependence from 32 independent density manipulations of milkweed aphids (Aphis nerii) in laboratory and field experiments. This substantial variation in intraspecific density dependence is associated with temperature and host-plant species. 2. It is reported that as population growth rate increases, density dependence becomes more strongly negative, suggesting that the monotonic definition of density dependence used in many common population models is appropriate for these aphids, and that population growth rate and carrying capacity are not directly proportional. 3. For populations that conform to these assumptions, population growth rate may be widely applicable as a predictor of the strength of density dependence.