Clinical prediction of thrombectomy eligibility: A systematic review and 4-item decision tree

被引:15
作者
Koster, Gaia T. [1 ]
Nguyen, T. Truc My [1 ]
van Zwet, Erik W. [2 ]
Garcia, Bjarty L. [3 ]
Rowling, Hannah R. [1 ]
Bosch, J. [4 ]
Schonewille, Wouter J. [5 ,6 ]
Velthuis, Birgitta K. [7 ]
van den Wijngaard, Ido R. [8 ]
den Hertog, Heleen M. [9 ,10 ]
Roos, Yvo B. W. E. M. [11 ]
van Walderveen, Marianne A. A. [12 ]
Wermer, Marieke J. H. [1 ]
Kruyt, Nyika D. [1 ]
机构
[1] Leiden Univ, Dept Neurol, Med Ctr, Leiden, Netherlands
[2] Leiden Univ, Dept Med Stat, Med Ctr, Leiden, Netherlands
[3] Leiden Univ, Dept Publ Hlth & Primary Care, Med Ctr, Leiden, Netherlands
[4] RAV Hollands Midden, Dept Res & Dev, Leiden, Netherlands
[5] St Antonius Hosp, Dept Neurol, Nieuwegein, Netherlands
[6] Brain Ctr Rudolf Magnus, Dept Neurol & Neurosurg, Utrecht, Netherlands
[7] Univ Med Ctr Utrecht, Dept Radiol, Utrecht, Netherlands
[8] Haaglanden Med Ctr, Dept Neurol, The Hague, Netherlands
[9] Med Spectrum Twente, Dept Neurol, Enschede, Netherlands
[10] Isala Clin, Dept Neurol, Zwolle, Netherlands
[11] Acad Med Ctr, Dept Neurol, Amsterdam, Netherlands
[12] Leiden Univ, Dept Radiol, Med Ctr, Leiden, Netherlands
关键词
Acute ischemic stroke; clinical scale; endovascular thrombectomy; intra-arterial thrombectomy; large vessel occlusion; prehospital; ACUTE ISCHEMIC-STROKE; LARGE VESSEL OCCLUSION; HEALTH-CARE PROFESSIONALS; ENDOVASCULAR TREATMENT; INTRAARTERIAL TREATMENT; PREHOSPITAL SCALE; EARLY MANAGEMENT; SEVERITY SCALE; DESIGN; THROMBOLYSIS;
D O I
10.1177/1747493018801225
中图分类号
R74 [神经病学与精神病学];
学科分类号
摘要
Background A clinical large anterior vessel occlusion (LAVO)-prediction scale could reduce treatment delays by allocating intra-arterial thrombectomy (IAT)-eligible patients directly to a comprehensive stroke center. Aim To subtract, validate and compare existing LAVO-prediction scales, and develop a straightforward decision support tool to assess IAT-eligibility. Methods We performed a systematic literature search to identify LAVO-prediction scales. Performance was compared in a prospective, multicenter validation cohort of the Dutch acute Stroke study (DUST) by calculating area under the receiver operating curves (AUROC). With group lasso regression analysis, we constructed a prediction model, incorporating patient characteristics next to National Institutes of Health Stroke Scale (NIHSS) items. Finally, we developed a decision tree algorithm based on dichotomized NIHSS items. Results We identified seven LAVO-prediction scales. From DUST, 1316 patients (35.8% LAVO-rate) from 14 centers were available for validation. FAST-ED and RACE had the highest AUROC (both >0.81, p < 0.01 for comparison with other scales). Group lasso analysis revealed a LAVO-prediction model containing seven NIHSS items (AUROC 0.84). With the GACE (Gaze, facial Asymmetry, level of Consciousness, Extinction/inattention) decision tree, LAVO is predicted (AUROC 0.76) for 61% of patients with assessment of only two dichotomized NIHSS items, and for all patients with four items. Conclusion External validation of seven LAVO-prediction scales showed AUROCs between 0.75 and 0.83. Most scales, however, appear too complex for Emergency Medical Services use with prehospital validation generally lacking. GACE is the first LAVO-prediction scale using a simple decision tree as such increasing feasibility, while maintaining high accuracy. Prehospital prospective validation is planned.
引用
收藏
页码:530 / 539
页数:10
相关论文
共 42 条
[1]   Endovascular Thrombectomy for Acute Ischemic Stroke A Meta-analysis [J].
Badhiwala, Jetan H. ;
Nassiri, Farshad ;
Alhazzani, Waleed ;
Selim, Magdy H. ;
Farrokhyar, Forough ;
Spears, Julian ;
Kulkarni, Abhaya V. ;
Singh, Sheila ;
Alqahtani, Abdulrahman ;
Rochwerg, Bram ;
Alshahrani, Mohammad ;
Murty, Naresh K. ;
Alhazzani, Adel ;
Yarascavitch, Blake ;
Reddy, Kesava ;
Zaidat, Osama O. ;
Almenawer, Saleh A. .
JAMA-JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN MEDICAL ASSOCIATION, 2015, 314 (17) :1832-1843
[2]   A Randomized Trial of Intraarterial Treatment for Acute Ischemic Stroke [J].
Berkhemer, O. A. ;
Fransen, P. S. S. ;
Beumer, D. ;
van den Berg, L. A. ;
Lingsma, H. F. ;
Yoo, A. J. ;
Schonewille, W. J. ;
Vos, J. A. ;
Nederkoorn, P. J. ;
Wermer, M. J. H. ;
van Walderveen, M. A. A. ;
Staals, J. ;
Hofmeijer, J. ;
van Oostayen, J. A. ;
Nijeholt, G. J. Lycklama A. ;
Boiten, J. ;
Brouwer, P. A. ;
Emmer, B. J. ;
de Bruijn, S. F. ;
van Dijk, L. C. ;
Kappelle, L. J. ;
Lo, R. H. ;
Van Dijk, E. J. ;
de Vries, J. ;
de Kort, P. L. M. ;
van Rooij, W. J. J. ;
van den Berg, J. S. P. ;
van Hasselt, B. A. A. M. ;
Aerden, L. A. M. ;
Dallinga, R. J. ;
Visser, M. C. ;
Bot, J. C. J. ;
Vroomen, P. C. ;
Eshghi, O. ;
Schreuder, T. H. C. M. L. ;
Heijboer, R. J. J. ;
Keizer, K. ;
Tielbeek, A. V. ;
den Hertog, H. M. ;
Gerrits, D. G. ;
van den Berg-Vos, R. M. ;
Karas, G. B. ;
Steyerberg, E. W. ;
Flach, H. Z. ;
Marquering, H. A. ;
Sprengers, M. E. S. ;
Jenniskens, S. F. M. ;
Beenen, L. F. M. ;
van den Berg, R. ;
Koudstaal, P. J. .
NEW ENGLAND JOURNAL OF MEDICINE, 2015, 372 (01) :11-20
[3]  
Brazis PW, 2012, LOCALIZATION CLIN NE, P321
[4]   Group descent algorithms for nonconvex penalized linear and logistic regression models with grouped predictors [J].
Breheny, Patrick ;
Huang, Jian .
STATISTICS AND COMPUTING, 2015, 25 (02) :173-187
[5]   Endovascular Therapy for Ischemic Stroke with Perfusion-Imaging Selection [J].
Campbell, B. C. V. ;
Mitchell, P. J. ;
Kleinig, T. J. ;
Dewey, H. M. ;
Churilov, L. ;
Yassi, N. ;
Yan, B. ;
Dowling, R. J. ;
Parsons, M. W. ;
Oxley, T. J. ;
Wu, T. Y. ;
Brooks, M. ;
Simpson, M. A. ;
Miteff, F. ;
Levi, C. R. ;
Krause, M. ;
Harrington, T. J. ;
Faulder, K. C. ;
Steinfort, B. S. ;
Priglinger, M. ;
Ang, T. ;
Scroop, R. ;
Barber, P. A. ;
McGuinness, B. ;
Wijeratne, T. ;
Phan, T. G. ;
Chong, W. ;
Chandra, R. V. ;
Bladin, C. F. ;
Badve, M. ;
Rice, H. ;
de Villiers, L. ;
Ma, H. ;
Desmond, P. M. ;
Donnan, G. A. ;
Davis, S. M. .
NEW ENGLAND JOURNAL OF MEDICINE, 2015, 372 (11) :1009-1018
[6]   COMPARING THE AREAS UNDER 2 OR MORE CORRELATED RECEIVER OPERATING CHARACTERISTIC CURVES - A NONPARAMETRIC APPROACH [J].
DELONG, ER ;
DELONG, DM ;
CLARKEPEARSON, DI .
BIOMETRICS, 1988, 44 (03) :837-845
[7]   NIHSS score and arteriographic findings in acute ischemic stroke [J].
Fischer, U ;
Arnold, M ;
Nedeltchev, K ;
Brekenfeld, C ;
Ballinari, P ;
Remonda, L ;
Schroth, G ;
Mattle, HP .
STROKE, 2005, 36 (10) :2121-2125
[8]   Time to Reperfusion and Treatment Effect for Acute Ischemic Stroke A Randomized Clinical Trial [J].
Fransen, Puck S. S. ;
Berkhemer, Olvert A. ;
Lingsma, Hester F. ;
Beumer, Debbie ;
van den Berg, Lucie A. ;
Yoo, Albert J. ;
Schonewille, Wouter J. ;
Vos, Jan Albert ;
Nederkoorn, Paul J. ;
Wermer, Marieke J. H. ;
van Walderveen, Marianne A. A. ;
Staals, Julie ;
Hofmeijer, Jeannette ;
van Oostayen, Jacques A. ;
Nijeholt, Geert J. Lycklama a ;
Boiten, Jelis ;
Brouwer, Patrick A. ;
Emmer, Bart J. ;
de Bruijn, Sebastiaan F. ;
van Dijk, Lukas C. ;
Kappelle, L. Jaap ;
Lo, Rob H. ;
van Dijk, Ewoud J. ;
de Vries, Joost ;
de Kort, Paul L. M. ;
van den Berg, J. S. Peter ;
van Hasselt, Boudewijn A. A. M. ;
Aerden, Leo A. M. ;
Dallinga, Rene J. ;
Visser, Marieke C. ;
Bot, Joseph C. J. ;
Vroomen, Patrick C. ;
Eshghi, Omid ;
Schreuder, Tobien H. C. M. L. ;
Heijboer, Roel J. J. ;
Keizer, Koos ;
Tielbeek, Alexander V. ;
den Hertog, Heleen M. ;
Gerrits, Dick G. ;
van den Berg-Vos, Renske M. ;
Karas, Giorgos B. ;
Steyerberg, Ewout W. ;
Flach, H. Zwenneke ;
Marquering, Henk A. ;
Sprengers, Marieke E. S. ;
Jenniskens, Sjoerd F. M. ;
Beenen, Ludo F. M. ;
van den Berg, Rene ;
Koudstaal, Peter J. ;
van Zwam, Wim H. .
JAMA NEUROLOGY, 2016, 73 (02) :190-196
[9]   Sparse inverse covariance estimation with the graphical lasso [J].
Friedman, Jerome ;
Hastie, Trevor ;
Tibshirani, Robert .
BIOSTATISTICS, 2008, 9 (03) :432-441
[10]   Randomized Assessment of Rapid Endovascular Treatment of Ischemic Stroke [J].
Goyal, M. ;
Demchuk, A. M. ;
Menon, B. K. ;
Eesa, M. ;
Rempel, J. L. ;
Thornton, J. ;
Roy, D. ;
Jovin, T. G. ;
Willinsky, R. A. ;
Sapkota, B. L. ;
Dowlatshahi, D. ;
Frei, D. F. ;
Kamal, N. R. ;
Montanera, W. J. ;
Poppe, A. Y. ;
Ryckborst, K. J. ;
Silver, F. L. ;
Shuaib, A. ;
Tampieri, D. ;
Williams, D. ;
Bang, O. Y. ;
Baxter, B. W. ;
Burns, P. A. ;
Choe, H. ;
Heo, J. -H. ;
Holmstedt, C. A. ;
Jankowitz, B. ;
Kelly, M. ;
Linares, G. ;
Mandzia, J. L. ;
Shankar, J. ;
Sohn, S. -I. ;
Swartz, R. H. ;
Barber, P. A. ;
Coutts, S. B. ;
Smith, E. E. ;
Morrish, W. F. ;
Weill, A. ;
Subramaniam, S. ;
Mitha, A. P. ;
Wong, J. H. ;
Lowerison, M. W. ;
Sajobi, T. T. ;
Hill, M. D. .
NEW ENGLAND JOURNAL OF MEDICINE, 2015, 372 (11) :1019-1030