Differential phosphorylation of the retinoblastoma protein by G(1)/S cyclin-dependent kinases

The retinoblastoma tumor suppressor protein, pRB, is inactivated by phosphorylation. While existing evidence is strong that such phosphorylation is mediated by one or more cyclin dependent kinases (CDKs) active during G(1)/S-1 it remains unclear which of the various CDKs is responsible. We show here that three candidate pRB inactivating kinases, CDK4-cyclin D1, CDK2-cyclin E, and CDK2-cyclin A, phosphorylate pRB differentially, each on a subset of authentic pRB phosphorylation sites. Notably, two neighboring pRB phosphate accepters, threonine 821 and threonine 826, which have previously been implicated in the regulation of LXCXE protein binding, are phosphorylated by different CDKs. We demonstrate that phosphorylation by either CDK2-cyclin A, which phosphorylates T821, or CDK4-cyclin D1, which phosphorylates threonine 826, can disable pRB for subsequent binding of an LXCXE, protein. However, only one of these two kinases, CDK2-cyclin A, can dissociate a pre-existing LXCXE protein-pRB complex. We provide evidence that prior binding of an LXCXE protein blocks access to certain residues specifically targeted by CDK4-cyclin D1, explaining the inability of this kinase to resolve such complexes. While these results are not direct proof of the relevance of differential pRB phosphorylation in cells, our findings support a model whereby full phosphorylation of pRB may require the action of more than one kinase and explains how such differential phosphorylation by different CDKs might translate into a differential regulation of downstream effector pathways.