Treatment outcome in endodontics: The Toronto Study. Phases I and II: Orthograde retreatment

The 4- to 6-year outcome of orthograde retreatment was assessed for Phases I and II of the Toronto Study. In total, 523 teeth in 444 patients were retreated. With 395 teeth lost to follow-up and 25 extracted, 103 teeth (34% recall) were examined by two independent, blinded, calibrated examiners for outcome: "healed" (absence of apical periodontitis, signs, or symptoms) or "diseased" (presence of apical periodontitis, signs, or symptoms). The "healed" rate (81%) differed significantly for preoperative apical periodontitis (absent, 97%; present, 78%) and perforation (absent, 89%; present, 42%). Logistic regression revealed an increased risk of disease for preoperative perforation and adequate root filling quality, and postoperative lack of definitive restoration (odds ratios=26.5, 6.6, and 14.0, respectively). Without perforation, inadequate intraoperative root filling length was also identified (odds ratio=6.8). This study suggested that apical periodontitis, although a strong predictor, was secondary to preoperative perforation and root filling quality, and to postoperative restoration, in predicting the outcome of retreatment.