The biophysical effects of a single impact load on human and bovine articular cartilage

Impact injury to a joint is a known risk factor for the subsequent development of secondary osteoarthritis. An in vitro model, employing a drop-tower loading machine, was used to examine the effect of an impact load on isolated articular cartilage explants from human and bovine femoral heads. Two different types of impact experiment were performed. In the first, 4 mm diameter explants were loaded using a plane-ended impactor. In the second, a modified impactor was developed that had a central 4 mm diameter plane-ended indentor which was used to load the centre of 8 mm. diameter explants. This enabled the unloaded outer ring of each explant to be compared with the loaded central core. The modulus values measured using the impactor were found to be higher, compared with the indentor in both species. Scanning electron microscopy showed that cartilage surrounding the loaded central region of the 8 mm explants protected the indented tissue, and these explants showed less damage than the 4 mm samples that were fully impacted. In addition, human cartilage was found to be less damaged than bovine, possibly as a consequence of the different structure as well as of a greater thickness. Both the source of the tissue and the nature of the impact affected the type of damage observed.