The incidence of recurrence after endoscopic carpal tunnel release

Endoscopic carpal tunnel release has been used to decompress the median nerve in carpal tunnel syndrome for over the past decade, with an advantage (over the traditional "open" release) being decreased pain in the postoperative period. The goals of this study were to attempt to define the recurrence rate after endoscopic carpal tunnel release and to determine if it differs from that of open technique. The charts of 191 consecutive carpal tunnel syndrome patients treated operatively at the University of Missouri were reviewed. For this study. recurrent carpal tunnel syndrome was defined as documented cases in which the symptoms had resolved following surgical release but subsequently recurred. requiring surgical rerelease of the carpal tunnel. All endoscopic releases were performed using the: Chow two-portal technique. Statistical analysis was performed using Fisher's exact test. A total of 103 patient hands had open carpal tunnel releases: 88 were endoscopically released. Total follow-up time (from the initial release) averaged 29 months for the open group and 22 months for the endoscopic group. There were no recurrences in the open group and sis recurrences in the endoscopic group (7 percent, P = 0.008). All sis recurrences were in worker's compensation patients. The median time between endoscopic release and release was 8.5 months. There seems to be a statistically higher incidence of recurrence of carpal tunnel syndrome after endoscopic release compared with the traditional "open" release in our cases. Although the pathogenesis of this increased rate of recurrence is not clear, this should be considered when planning surgical release of the volar carpal ligament for carpal tunnel syndrome.