The Betts Cove Ophiolite, Newfoundland, Canada, records the initiation of seafloor spreading in an Ordovician marginal basin. Early lavas and sheeted dykes are composed of Low-Ti (<0.3 wt% TiO2) and Intermediate-Ti (0.3 to similar to 0.6 wt% TiO2) boninites. The boninites are overlain by arc theoliites, and then by sequence of calc-alkaline pyroclastics and tholeiitic lavas. Results of trace element melting models suggest that the Betts Cove Low-Ti boninites were extracted from a mantle source residual after 20-22% melting of fertile mantle, subsequently refertilized with minor amounts (<0.25%) of incompatible-element enriched components. Intermediate-Ti boninites were derived from a less depleted source (similar to 12% previous melting), fluxed by similar fertile components. The composition of the source mantle for different end-member boninite magmas is calculated, allowing the composition if the refertilizing components to be derived. The compositions of the refertilizing components are consistent with a mixture of fluid-mobile elements derived from dehydration of the subducting oceanic crust, by partial melting of that same crust, and by partial melting og subducted elements. The gradation from extremely compatible-element depleted boninites to less depleted boninitic and tholeiitic magmas implies the progressive involvement of less depleted mantle sources. This suggests a vertical compositional zonation of the mantle source, with less depleted mantle domains entering the wedge, perhaps in response to slab rollback and extension of the overriding plate.