The effect of formaldehyde, hydrogen peroxide and genetic detoxification of pertussis toxin on epitope recognition by murine monoclonal antibodies

The effect of detoxification of pertussis toxin (PT) for vaccine usage by either generic manipulation, hydrogen peroxide or formaldehyde treatment on epitope recognition by a large collection of murine monoclonal pertussis toxin antibodies (PT MAbs) was assessed in a solid-phase and a soluble phase enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA). The MAb binding patterns were found to be different in the two assays as the immobilization step appeared to cause conformational alterations in the native as well as the toxoided forms of PT According to the solid-phase ELISA, genetic, hydrogen peroxide and 0.35% formaldehyde detoxification of PT resulted in reduced epitope binding in 2.9, 31.4 and 78.1% of the MAbs, respectively In the soluble-phase ELISA, in which the MAbs were allowed to react with the toxoids or native toxin in solution, the percentages of MAbs showing decreased binding activity were 9.1, 50.0 and 71.4%, respectively. Stabilization of native PT and the genetically inactivated PT by 0.035% formaldehyde reduced the epitope binding activity in 50.0 and 8.7% of the MAbs, respectively. Increased antibody binding in the soluble-phase ELISA was observed in some of the toxoids: this ranged from 0% in the 0.35% formaldehyde-treated PT to 13.6% in the hydrogen peroxide-treated and 27.3% in the genetically detoxified PT. Regarding the effects of detoxification on epitopes recognized by PT-neutralizing MAbs in the soluble-phase ELISA, we found that treatment of PT with either 0.035%, 0.35% formaldehyde or hydrogen peroxide induced impairment of epitope binding in 72.7, 81.8 and 45.5% of the MAbs, respectively. In the genetically inactivated PT, the epitopes recognized by the neutralizing MAbs either appeared to remain intact or to show increased MAb binding activity. The epitope-binding patterns of several PT MAbs with mouse-protective properties varied considerably and were shown to be dependent out the detoxification procedure employed. The relevance of epitope alterations on PT as a vaccine component is discussed The results of the present study may have important implications for future quality assessment of PT for use in acellular pertussis vaccines. Copyright (C) 1996 Elsevier Science Ltd