The relationship between the slope angle and the landslide size derived from limit equilibrium simulations

Katz et al. (2014) carried out a study of controls on the size and geometry of landslides using two-dimensional discrete element numerical simulations. One of their conclusions is that in addition to the peak strength of the slope material, the initial slope angle is another factor that controls the amount of material available for landslides, thus the size, of the resultant landslide. It means that in steeper slopes, more material disintegrates for a given material strength, and consequently the produced landslide is larger. However, in our studies based on limit equilibrium simulations, the sliding mass volume decreases with the increasing slope angle for a given material strength, just contrary to the result of Katz et al. One possible explanation is that when the slope angle in our model increases, the geometry of the potential critical slip surface changes, leading to a decrease of the amount of material available for potential sliding that compensates the increasing gravity effect owing to the enlargement of the slope angle. It suggests that there exist different controls of the slope angle on the landslide size for given material strength. (C) 2015 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.