Phylogeographic studies in the tropical seaweed Cladophoropsis membranacea (Chlorophyta, Ulvophyceae) reveal a cryptic species complex

The seaweed Cladophoropsis membranacea (Hofman Bang ex. C. Agardh) Borgesen is a widely distributed species on coral reefs and along rocky coastlines throughout the tropics and subtropics. In a recent population-level survey openface >1600 individuals with eight microsatellite loci, a number of isolates from biogeographically disjunct locations could not be amplified for any of the loci. Nonamplifiable and amplifiable isolates co-occurred within the Canary Islands, Cape Verde Islands, and in the Caribbean. These unexpected results led to question whether or not C. membranacea is a single species. Phylogenetic relationships were evaluated using rDNA ITS1 and ITS2 sequence comparisons from 42 isolates sampled from a subset of 30 of the 66 locations. Four well-supported clades were identified. Sequence divergence within clades was <1%, whereas between-clade divergence was 2%-3%. Intraindividual variation was extremely low with no effects on the analysis. A strong, but imperfect, correspondence was found between ITS clades and amplifiable microsatellite loci. It is concluded that C. membranacea consists of three cryptic species. Using Pacific isolates as an outgroup, the most basal clade included the Central Canary Islands, Cape Verde, and Bonaire (Caribbean) isolates and thus spanned the widest latitude. Two derived sister clades consisted of a southern transtropical group stretching across the SE Caribbean to the Cape Verde Islands and African coast (but not the Canary Islands) and a NE-Canary Island-Mediterranean clade that also included the Red Sea. The detection of overlapping biogeographic distributions highlights the importance of ecotypic differentiation with respect to temperature and the importance of shifting sea surface isotherms that have driven periodic extinctions and recolonizations of the Canary Islands-a crossroads of marine floral exchange-since the last glacial maximum.