Use of the SHMAK clarity tube for measuring water clarity: comparison with the black disk method

A metre-long transparent tube for measuring visual water clarity was developed as part of the New Zealand Stream Health Monitoring and Assessment Kit (SHMAK) for use by non-scientists. Water clarity measured using the tube (the horizontal sighting range of a black target) was compared with that measured using the standard "black disk" method (in which a black target is viewed horizontally underwater) to determine the feasibility of estimating black disk clarities from clarity tube readings. Readings using the two methods showed good agreement for waters with clarity <c. 50 cm. In clearer waters the slope of the relationship depends on the reflectivity of the background material used in the clarity tube. With a reflective background (white, reflectance c. 75%; or grey, reflectance c. 55%), the clarity tube readings are directly proportional and approximately equal to the black disk readings. With a black background (reflectance c. 5.5%), clarity tube readings >c. 50 cm are lower than the black disk visibility and follow a logarithmic relationship with visibility, which enables useful readings to be made in clearer water. Independent testing of the relationship showed that black disk visibilities may be predicted with reasonable confidence in waters that contain very low concentrations of dissolved humic materials (yellow substance). In waters that are noticeably brown-coloured, the relationship is less consistent especially at black disk visibilities of more than 1.5 m. Recommendations are given for the use of the clarity tube.