Constraints on voltage sensor movement in the shaker K+ channel

In nerve and muscle cells, the voltage-gated opening and closing of cation-selective ion channels is accompanied by the translocation of 12-14 elementary charges across the membrane's electric field. Although most of these charges are carried by residues in the S4 helix of the gating module of these channels, the precise nature of their physical movement is currently the topic of spirited debate. Broadly speaking, two classes of models have emerged: those that suggest that small-scale motions can account for the extensive charge displacement, and those that invoke a much larger physical movement. In the most recent incarnation of the latter type of model, which is based on structural and functional data from the archaebacterial K+ channel KvAP, a "voltage-sensor paddle" comprising a helix-turn-helix of S3-S4 translocates similar to 20 angstrom through the bilayer during the gating cycle (Jiang, Y., A. Lee, J. Chen, V. Ruta, M. Cadene, B. T. Chait, and R. MacKinnon. 2003. Nature. 423: 33-41; Jiang, Y., V. Ruta, J. Chen, A. Lee, and R. MacKinnon. 2003. Nature. 423: 42-48.; Ruta, V., J. Chen, and R. MacKinnon. 2005. Cell. 123: 463-475). We used two methods to test for analogous motions in the Shaker K+ channel, each examining the aqueous exposure of residues near S3. In the first, we employed a pore-blocking maleimide reagent (Blaustein, R. O., P. A. Cole, C. Williams, and C. Miller. 2000. Nat. Struct. Biol. 7: 309-311) to probe for state-dependent changes in the chemical reactivity of substituted cysteines; in the second, we tested the state-dependent accessibility of a tethered biotin to external streptavidin (Qiu, X. Q., K. S. Jakes, A. Finkelstein, and S. L. Slatin. 1994. J. Biol. Chem. 269: 7483-7488; Slatin, S. L., X. Q. Qiu, K. S. Jakes, and A. Finkelstein. 1994. Nature. 371: 158-161). In both types of experiments, residues predicted to lie near the top of S3 did not exhibit any change in aqueous exposure during the gating cycle. This lack of state dependence argues against large-scale movements, either axially or radially, of Shaker's S3-S4 voltage-sensor paddle.