Comparison of ischemic response during exercise and dobutamine Echocardiography in patients with left main coronary artery disease

Objectives. This study sought to compare manifestations of myocardial ischemia evoked by exercise and dobutamine echocardiography in patients with left main coronary artery disease. Background. During exercise testing! left ventricular cavity dilation, marked ST segment depression and blood pressure decrease indicate severe coronary artery disease. Whether these signs are comparably evoked by dobutamine echocardiography has not been described. Methods. Fifty-four patients who underwent stress echocardiography (36 exercise, 18 dobutamine) and coronary angiography showing greater than or equal to 50% left main stenosis were analyzed. Electrocardiographic and blood pressure changes, symptoms, wall motion score indexes and sensitivity for coronary artery disease were compared. In 47 patients, the left ventricular endocardium was traced to quantify volumes and ejection fraction. Results. Stress-induced regional mall motion abnormalities developed in 91% of patients; this was not different on exercise (89%) or dobutamine echocardiography (93%). Rate pressure product and wall motion score index, similar at rest, tended to be higher after exercise than after dobutamine stress (p = 0.07 and p = 0.05, respectively). ST segment depression greater than or equal to 1 mm was more common with exercise (p = 0.005). Ejection fraction and end-systolic and end-diastolic volume indexes were comparable at rest in both groups. With exercise, ejection fraction decreased in 87% of patients, and end-systolic and end-diastolic volume indexes increased in 80%. In contrast, with dobutamine, decreased ejection fraction and increased volume indexes were infrequent. Ejection fraction was lower ([mean +/- SD] 45 +/- 19% vs, 54 +/- 12%, p = 0.007) and end-diastolic (69 +/- 26 vs. 50 +/- 17 ml/m(2), p = 0.02) and end-systolic (39 +/- 20 vs. 24 +/- 13 ml/m(2), p = 0.02) volume indexes were higher after exercise than after dobutamine stress. Conclusions. On the basis of changes in regional wall motion, both dobutamine and exercise echocardiography have a comparable high sensitivity in diagnosing myocardial ischemia in left main coronary artery disease. However, conventional signs of severe myocardial ischemia, including left ventricular cavity dilation and marked ST segment depression, occur more often with exercise than with dobutamine echocardiography.