Value of Doppler echocardiography in the detection of low-grade rejections after cardiac transplantation

Modifications of the diastolic parameters pressure half-time (PHT) and isovolumic relaxation time (IVRT), recorded using cardiac Doppler echocardiography (CDE), were studied in 23 heart transplant recipients and compared to the results of 345 endomyocardial biopsies (EMB) performed on the same day. Two different protocols, analyzing respectively (1) a decrease of 20 % or more in IVRT and/or PHT with respect to the mean and (2) a decrease of 20 % or more in IVRT and/or PHT with respect to its preceding value, were used to evaluate the efficiency of CDE in diagnosing mild and moderate rejections. When a mild rejection was detected by EMB, a statistically significant decrease was found in the average CDE parameter values of the patient population. However, these variations were weak and did not differ from the spontaneous variations observed in each patient in the absence of rejection. Thus, it is not surprising that the sensitivity of CDE in the detection of mild rejections was very low (45 %) using the most sensitive protocol (variations of the parameters from their preceding value). We conclude that CDE alone does not seem to be sufficient to perform the noninvasive diagnosis of low-grade rejections and must be complemented by other noninvasive methods.