Multicenter study of oxygen-insensitive handheld glucose point-of-care testing in critical care hospital ambulatory patients in the United States and Canada

Objectives: Existing handheld glucose meters are glucose oxidase (GO)-based, Oxygen side reactions can introduce oxygen dependency, increase potential error, and limit clinical use. Our primary objectives were to: a) introduce a new glucose dehydrogenase (GD)-based electrochemical biosensor for point-of-care testing; b) determine the oxygen-sensitivity of GO-and GD-based electrochemical biosensor test strips; and c) evaluate the clinical performance of the new Go-based glucose meter system in critical care/hospital/ambulatory patients. Design: Multicenter study sites compared glucose levels determined with GD-based biosensors to glucose levels determined in whole brood with a perchloric acid deproteinization hexokinase reference method, One site also studied GO-based biosensors and venous plasma glucose measured with a chemistry analyzer, Biosensor test strips were used with a handheld glucose monitoring system, Bench and clinical oxygen sensitivity, hematocrit effect, and precision were evaluated. Setting: The study was performed at eight U.S. medical centers and one Canadian medical center. Patients: There were 1,248 patients, Results: The GO-based biosensor was oxygen sensitive. The new GD-based biosensor was oxygen-insensitive. GD-based bio sensor performance was acceptable: 2,104 (96.1%) of 2,189 glucose meter measurements were within +/-15 mg/dL (+/-0.83 mmol/L) for glucose revels of less than or equal to 100 mg/dL (less than or equal to 5.55 mmol/L) or within +/-15% for glucose levels of >100 mg/dL, compared with the whole-blood reference method results, With the GD-based biosensor, the percentages of glucose measurements that were not within the error tolerance were comparable for different specimen types and clinical groups, Bracket predictive values were acceptable for glucose levels used in therapeutic management, Conclusions: The performance of GD-based, oxygen-insensitive, handheld glucose testing was technically suitable for arterial specimens in critical care patients, cord blood and heelstick specimens in neonates, and capillary and venous specimens in other patients, Multicenter findings benchmark the performance of bedside glucose testing devices, With the new +/-15 mg/dL --> 100 mg/dL --> +/-15% accuracy criterion, point-of-care systems for handheld glucose testing should score 95% (or better), as compared with the recommended reference method, Physiologic changes, preanalytical factors, confounding variables, and treatment goals must be taken into consideration when interpreting glucose results, especially in critically ill patients, for whom arterial blood glucose measurements wilt reflect systemic glucose levels.