Admissibility of exact conditional tests of stochastic order

Consider the problem of testing for independence against stochastic order in a 2xJ contingency table, with two treatments and J ordered categories. By conditioning on the margins, the null hypothesis becomes simple. Careful selection of the conditional alternative hypothesis then allows the problem to be formulated as one of a class of problems for which the minimal complete class of admissible tests is known. The exact versions of many common tests, such as t-tests and the Smirnov test, are shown to be inadmissible, and thus the non-randomized versions are overly conservative. The proportional hazards and proportional odds tests are shown to be admissible for a given data set and size. A new result allows a proof of the admissibility of convex hull and adaptive tests for all data sets and sizes. (C) 1998 Elsevier Science B.V.