Why a ''benign'' mutation kills enzyme activity. Structure-based analysis of the A176V mutant of Saccharomyces cerevisiae L-asparaginase I

A conservative and apparently harmless A176V mutation in intracellular S. cerevisiae L-asparaginase (ScerAI) completely abolishes the enzyme activity. Sequence and structural comparisons with type II bacterial L-asparaginases show that the mutated residue is in a very conservative region and plays a vital role in the cohesion of functional tetramers of these enzymes through participation in side-chain...main-chain (Ser) O gamma...O (Ala) hydrogen bonds across the tetramer interface. The fact that bacterial L-asparaginases of type I show less conservation in this region suggests that they may have different quaternary structure while adopting the subunit fold and intimate dimer architecture of type II enzymes. A comparison of all available sequences of microbial L-asparaginases confirms that separate intra-and extra-cellular enzymes evolved in prokaryotes and eukaryotes independently. However, an analysis of the available complete genome sequences reveals a surprising fact that Haemophilus influenzae possesses only a type II asparaginase while the archaebacterium Methanococcus jannaschii has a type I gene, but not a type II.