A possible pharmacological explanation for quinacrine failure to treat prion diseases:: pharmacokinetic investigations in a ovine model of scrapie

1 Quinacrine was reported to have a marked in vitro antiprion action in mouse neuroblastoma cells. On compassionate grounds, quinacrine was administered to Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease patients, despite the absence of preclinical in vivo studies to evaluate efficacy. Quinacrine failed to provide therapeutic benefit. The aim of the study was to investigate possible pharmacokinetic and/or pharmacodynamic explanations for the discrepancy between the proven action of quinacrine in vitro and its lack of clinical efficacy. 2 We conducted in vitro experiments reproducing the culture conditions in which antiprion effects had been previously observed and recalculated the EC50 by determining the actual extracellular (120 nM) and intracellular (6713 nM) quinacrine neuroblastoma concentrations with the reported quinacrine EC50 (300 nM). 3 A randomized clinical trial in scrapie-affected ewes confirmed the absence of therapeutic benefit of quinacrine. The in vivo quinacrine exposure was evaluated in a pharmacokinetic investigation in healthy ewes. Cerebrospinal fluid concentrations (<10.6 and 55 nM after administration of therapeutic and toxic quinacrine doses, respectively) were much lower than the quinacrine extracellular neuroblastoma concentrations corresponding to the reported EC50. The total brain tissue concentrations (3556 nM) obtained after a repeated therapeutic dosage regimen were within the range of the intracellular neuroblastoma quinacrine concentrations. 4 In conclusion, in order to avoid in vivo trials for which failure can be predicted, the measurement in vitro of the antiprion EC50 in both intra- and extracellular biophases should be determined. It can then be established if these in vitro antiprion concentrations are achievable in vivo.